dot-iu-cutter v0.5 WS-Q5 Registry Substrate — Production Apply Verification Result

Phase: v0_5_WS_Q5_registry_substrate_production_apply · Date: 2026-05-18 Method: catalog-level only (pg_catalog / information_schema); ZERO pg_get_*def() rendered-string equality (C-07 lesson). Read-only.

apply_occurred: false (BLOCKED — permission denied, 0 objects created)
verification_outcome: POST-APPLY VERIFICATION NOT APPLICABLE
baseline_recheck: ALL UNCHANGED (production intact)
production_authorized_state: blocked_pending_reauthorization

---

1. Why post-apply verification is not applicable

The authorized apply aborted at statement 1 with permission denied for schema cutter_governance (connecting role directus lacks CREATE; schema owned by workflow_admin). ON_ERROR_STOP=1 halted psql; the transaction never reached COMMIT and was rolled back on session close. Zero of the 12 tables were created. Therefore the post-apply verification matrix (12 tables / 12 PK / 8 FK / 4 UNIQUE) cannot pass — not due to any schema defect, but because the apply did not execute. Each row below records the expected-vs-observed state honestly.

2. Verification matrix (catalog — observed after the blocked attempt)

Check	Assertion (expected if apply had succeeded)	Catalog basis	Observed	Result
TV-1	12 new tables present	pg_tables IN (12 names)	0 of 12 present	FAIL (apply blocked — not created)
TV-3	cutter_governance table count = 24	pg_tables	12 (baseline)	FAIL (apply blocked)
KC-1	+12 PK (total 24)	pg_constraint contype='p'	p=12 (baseline)	FAIL (apply blocked)
KC-2	+8 FK (total 27)	pg_constraint contype='f'	f=19 (baseline)	FAIL (apply blocked)
KC-3	new FK schema-qualified cutter_governance↔cutter_governance	pg_constraint joined pg_namespace	no new FK to assert	N/A (apply blocked)
KC-4	+4 UNIQUE (total 6)	pg_constraint contype='u'	u=2 (baseline)	FAIL (apply blocked)
KC-6	0 new CHECK / 0 trigger on new tables	pg_constraint contype='c'; pg_trigger	c=1 (pre-existing baseline); no new tables	N/A (no new tables)
CV-4	0 column DEFAULT on new tables	information_schema.columns	no new columns	N/A (apply blocked)
NH-3	0 new enum type	pg_type typtype='e'	0	PASS (no enum introduced)
AO-1	diff = exactly +12 tables + constraints	pg_class/pg_constraint	diff = 0 (nothing added)	N/A — nothing applied
AO-4	system_identifier unchanged	pg_control_system()	7611578671664259111 == pre	PASS
AO-5	0 rows in 12 new tables	(tables absent)	no new tables exist	N/A (apply blocked)
NG-*	any unintended object / ALTER / GRANT / row	pg_catalog	none — production untouched	PASS (no side effects)

3. Baseline reconfirmation (the substantive PASS — production intact)

metric                pre_apply   post_attempt   verdict
system_identifier     7611578671664259111  7611578671664259111  UNCHANGED  PASS
cg_table_count(r)     12          12             UNCHANGED  PASS
target_12_present     NONE        NONE           UNCHANGED  PASS  (0 created)
primary_key (p)       12          12             UNCHANGED  PASS
foreign_key (f)       19          19             UNCHANGED  PASS
unique (u)            2           2              UNCHANGED  PASS
check (c)             1           1              UNCHANGED  PASS
view (v)              12          12             UNCHANGED  PASS
index (i)             18          18             UNCHANGED  PASS
existing_12_tables    intact      intact         UNCHANGED  PASS
zero_data_loss        n/a         yes            PASS

4. Row counts

new_table_row_counts: N/A — none of the 12 tables exist (apply blocked).
no system metadata rows expected and none could have been written (no DML
authorized; no objects created).

5. Verdict

post_apply_verification: NOT_APPLICABLE (apply BLOCKED before any object created)
schema_defect_detected: NONE — the DDL artifact was never executed past
  statement 1; the block is an authorization-scoping gap, not a DDL fault.
production_state: UNCHANGED / INTACT / zero data loss
fail_action_taken: STOP_AND_ESCALATE (rollback package NOT applicable — its
  precondition "12 tables created & empty" is unmet; nothing to invert).
  No schema self-fix, no role/GRANT change, no improvisation.
production_authorized: false (re-authorization required — see report)

6. Statements

• QG: every check catalog-level; no rendered-string equality. Read-only only; no mutation, no Directus, no CUT/VERIFY, no git commit.
• Self-advance PROHIBITED — doc 2 of 3; STOP → route GPT/User.

Companion files: production-apply-execution-log, production-apply-report.