dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — S2 Planner Commit & Writer Design Bridge · Macro-Task Closeout Report

doc 5 of 5 · 2026-05-19 · STOP → route GPT/User

result: S2_PLANNER_COMMITTED + WRITER_DESIGN_BRIDGE_READY
kb_read: confirmed · kb_upload: confirmed (5/5 docs)
production_mutation: NONE · git: local feature-branch commit only · self_advance: PROHIBITED

1. Outcome (both PASS criteria met)

P_TRACK_planner:
  result: S2_PLANNER_COMMITTED
  commit: feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun  afb7bfc -> d66a60d
  files: cutter_agent/cutplan.py (548eabc5…) + tests/test_cutplan_snapshot.py (06e871e7…),
         646 insertions, 0 existing files modified; main 4367c83 UNCHANGED; tree clean
  gate: GPT R1 targeted-suite (cutplan 15/15, MARK 21/21; discover 128/1 = pre-existing
        baseline security-test issue, proven not an S2 regression)
W_TRACK_writer:
  result: WRITER_DESIGN_BRIDGE_READY (design/doc only — no writer code authored)
  delivered: verified production target (information_unit + unit_version two-layer
    birth-gate) re-confirmed read-only; minimal cut-plan-row → IU/unit_version mapping
    (doc 3); dot_config vocab found ALREADY SEEDED for a law_unit mapping (GAP-W3 reduced
    to a confirmation precheck); OD-W1..OD-W9 open decisions + risk register (doc 4)
  status: still BLOCKED for production until W-1 ruling + W-3 build + W-4 credentials +
    W-5 prod-write approval — but now has a concrete, code-ready design bridge.

2. Macro-goal questions answered

repo/branch/HEAD: /Users/nmhuyen/iu-cutter-build/repo/iu-cutter ·
  feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun · HEAD now d66a60d (was afb7bfc)
only_expected_S2_files: YES (2 untracked pre-commit; now committed; tree clean)
byte_exact_vs_readiness: YES (cutplan 548eabc5… / test 06e871e7… unchanged)
tests: cutplan 15/15 OK · MARK 21/21 OK · discover 128/1 (baseline-known, not regression)
S2_committed: YES (feature branch only; no merge/push/tag/deploy)
writer_designed_not_coded: YES (docs 3 & 4; no writer code; no production command invented)
NGUYEN_TAC/KIEN_TRUC IU-or-container: RECOMMENDED all-IU (keeps 60 + reconstruction) —
  GPT to rule OD-W1
DIEU unit_kind: RECOMMENDED law_unit (already in vocab) — OD-W2
parent/container: parent_or_container_ref by manifest address path; NULL parent for
  top-level, no synthetic root (keeps 60) — OD-W3
canonical_address: VERBATIM manifest ICX-CONST/<path> (N-4) — OD-W4
idempotency/collision: OD-1 key + UNIQUE(canonical_address) + pre-existence check — OD-W5
vocab dot_config seed: NONE needed for the recommended law_unit mapping (all keys present);
  confirmation precheck only — OD-W6
signing/credential: cutter_exec/DOT-991; real signing deferred; W-3 builds DB-isolated
  writer first, credentials at W-4 — OD-W7

3. Quality gates

QG1 planner commit precheck + tests, baseline vs regression distinguished : PASS (doc 1)
QG2 S2 committed on feature branch, no merge/push/deploy, verified         : PASS (doc 2)
QG3 production schema/vocab re-reviewed read-only                          : PASS (doc 3 §1-2)
QG4 minimal cut-plan-row → information_unit + unit_version mapping          : PASS (doc 3 §3-5)
QG5 writer open decisions + risk register for next phase                   : PASS (doc 4)
QG6 no writer code authored / no production command invented               : PASS
QG7 no production mutation                                                 : PASS (§4)
QG8 STOP after upload, route GPT/User                                      : PASS (§5)

4. Explicit no-mutation statement

production_mutation: NONE. No CUT · no VERIFY · no production DB/IU/Directus/vector write ·
  no source/version mutation · no deploy/restart · no merge/push/tag · no writer code ·
  no invented production command · no self-advance.
git_action_performed: ONE local commit on the existing feature branch (2 new files only),
  GPT-R1-authorized; main untouched; nothing pushed/tagged/merged; fully reversible
  (`git reset --hard afb7bfc`).
db_actions_performed: READ-ONLY information_schema / pg_catalog / dot_config SELECTs only.
kb: 5 documents created in v0.5-s2-planner-commit-and-writer-design-bridge/ (folder was empty).

5. Disposition — STOP → route GPT/User

result: S2_PLANNER_COMMITTED__WRITER_DESIGN_BRIDGE_READY
kb_path: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-s2-planner-commit-and-writer-design-bridge/
docs: [commit-precheck-and-test-result(1), s2-planner-commit-report(2),
       production-writer-mapping-design-brief(3), writer-open-decisions-and-risk-register(4),
       macro-task-closeout-report(5)]
decisions_required_from_GPT_User (each its own gate; NOT self-advanced):
  P-3 first cut-plan dry-run execution command-review of the committed planner (independent;
      net-zero; N-1 manifest regen+sha-verify is its precheck)
  W-1 rule OD-W1..OD-W9 (writer mapping/granularity/vocab/signing posture — doc 4)
  W-2 (only if OD-W6 picks non-seeded vocab) gated dot_config seed
  W-3 design→author→CI→commit a DB-isolated manifest→IU/unit_version writer + scratch-schema
      birth-gate dry-run
  W-4 cutter_exec/cutter_verify credential + production signing cycle
  W-5 production CUT command-review + SEPARATE explicit production-DB-write approval +
      governed VERIFY plan
forbidden_and_not_performed: CUT · VERIFY · production DB/IU write · deploy/restart ·
  merge/push/tag · source/version mutation · invented production command · self-advance.
next_action: STOP. Route to GPT/User for P-3 and the W-1 writer-decisions ruling.

doc 5 of 5. No production mutation. Self-advance PROHIBITED.