dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Deferred Source Family Seed Extension — NO-SEED-DRAFT

Phase: v0_5_deferred_source_family_grammar_binding_gate · Nature: design_only__no_execution · Date: 2026-05-18

⚠️ THIS IS A NO-SEED-DRAFT (QG6)

seed_extension_authored: NONE
dml_drafted: 0 statements ; dml_executed: 0
safe_seed_exists: false
generic_grammar_profile_added: false
schema_alter: none
reason: NO family among the 6 deferred is safely seedable in this gate.
decision_authority: GPT / User ONLY ; self_advance: PROHIBITED

1. Why there is no seed draft

Per the classification + recommendation companions, 0 of 6 deferred source families can be seeded safely now. A seed-extension SQL draft would, for every family, require at least one forbidden / unjustified precondition:

sql_entity:
  blocker: NOT a grammar-parsed document — it is a raw entity (WS-3 §3/§4).
  to seed as source_family would need: a FABRICATED grammar_profile (QG1 violation)
    OR a schema change to drop the NOT NULL grammar_profile_ref (forbidden now).
  -> NO SEED. Already represented by entity_kind 'sql_entity' (live).

code_artifact:
  blocker: raw entity / code artifact (WS-3 §4). Same as sql_entity.
  to seed would need: fabricated profile (QG1) OR schema change (forbidden).
  -> NO SEED. Covered by entity_kinds code_module / git_file (live).

internal_process:
  blocker: legitimate normative document, but NO ratified grammar profile exists
    for process structure. Minting one here = "generic grammar profile without
    clear justification" (GPT closeout still-forbidden).
  -> NO SEED. Requires a separate grammar-profile ratification sub-gate first.

architecture_note:
  blocker: legitimate normative document (mixed-authority prone), but NO ratified
    profile exists. Same as internal_process. Also out of WS-3 sample chain.
  -> NO SEED. Requires profile ratification sub-gate (defer_post_pilot).

report:
  blocker: modeling dimension UNRESOLVED — evidence document (needs profile) vs
    evidence artifact (entity via report_path). Cannot pick silently (QG7).
  -> NO SEED until RULING-3.

lesson:
  blocker: same unresolved document-vs-entity dimension as report.
  -> NO SEED until RULING-3.

2. What was deliberately NOT done (forbidden / unjustified)

-- NOT AUTHORED, NOT EXECUTED — listed only to make the refusal explicit:
--
--   ❌ INSERT INTO cutter_governance.source_family_registry (... 6 deferred ...)
--      -- impossible without a non-null grammar_profile_ref for each row
--   ❌ INSERT INTO cutter_governance.grammar_profile (... fake/generic profile ...)
--      -- QG1 violation + GPT closeout still-forbidden ("add generic grammar profile")
--   ❌ ALTER TABLE cutter_governance.source_family_registry
--        ALTER COLUMN grammar_profile_ref DROP NOT NULL;
--      -- schema ALTER + nullability change: explicitly forbidden in this gate
--   ❌ any source_kind / parser_strategy column add
--      -- schema DDL: Option D is DESIGN-ONLY, not executed here
--
-- Net SQL produced by this gate: ZERO statements. Nothing to run, nothing to roll back.

3. Conditional shape (illustrative ONLY — not a draft, not executable)

If, and only if, GPT/User later rules a specific path, the future (separately gated) seed would take one of these shapes. Shown so the decision is concrete — this is not an authored draft and must not be executed:

IF RULING-1 = Option D (schema revision, design then separate execution):
  future_path: a new schema cycle makes grammar_profile_ref nullable (or adds
    source_kind). ONLY THEN could sql_entity/code_artifact be seeded as families
    WITHOUT a grammar profile — and even then, likely they remain entity-only and
    are never seeded as source_family at all.

IF RULING-2/3 = author real profiles:
  future_path: a grammar-profile ratification sub-gate authors + sovereign-ratifies
    e.g. an 'internal-process-v1' profile (level_definitions + matcher config rows
    + address_template, WS-2 D3-style). Only after that profile is LIVE could a
    seed-extension command package add the internal_process family row pointing at
    the real profile_ref. Same pattern per ratified family.
  rule: each such family row, when finally drafted, MUST trace to (a) a ratified
    grammar_profile_ref and (b) a WS-2 D2 authority_semantics_default, with a
    paired verification + rollback (QG5) — authored in that future gate, not here.

4. Statements

• This file is explicitly a NO-SEED-DRAFT (QG6). Zero DML authored, zero executed. No fake/generic grammar profile. No schema ALTER. No nullability change. No family with unresolved modeling included (none included at all).
• No row was drafted because no row can currently trace to a ratified design authority (QG5 would be unmeetable for all 6).
• No DDL/GRANT/Directus/CUT/VERIFY/deploy/git. No execution (QG8).
• Self-advance PROHIBITED — doc 3 of 5; STOP after package → route GPT/User.

Companion: classification-and-options, recommendation-and-ruling-request, verification-and-rollback-plan, gate-report.