dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Cut-plan Dry-run & Writer Decision · Macro-Task Closeout Report

doc 6 of 6 · 2026-05-19 · STOP → route GPT/User

result: CUTPLAN_DRYRUN_PASS + WRITER_AUTHORING_BRIEF_READY
kb_read: confirmed · kb_upload: confirmed (6/6 docs)
production_mutation: NONE · git: none this phase · self_advance: PROHIBITED

1. Outcome (both PASS criteria met)

P_TRACK (cut-plan dry-run):
  result: CUTPLAN_DRYRUN_PASS  (RAN, artifact-only, net-zero — authorized by GPT
    P3_cutplan_dryrun "run … if safely possible", mutation artifact_only)
  HEAD: d66a60d (unchanged) · branch feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun · tree clean
  N-1 C-3 gate: PASS (manifest regenerated deterministically into /tmp; file sha
    7d56f3ce… == pinned, digest 9d908a62… == pinned, 60/4)
  run: exit 0, PASS, db_write NONE, production_touched false, 60 cands, Điều-44 excluded,
    reconstruction_ok, cut_plan_digest edcae74f… , re_run_equal true (2 runs identical;
    also == prior in-test value ⇒ cross-env determinism). 5 artifacts (sha in doc 2).
    Levels NT15/KT3/DIEU42, all enacted, 60 distinct OD-1 keys, scratch shredded.
W_TRACK (writer decisions/design):
  result: WRITER_AUTHORING_BRIEF_READY
  OD-W1..OD-W9: all PROPOSED with recommended option + reason (doc 3); NONE blocked by
    missing evidence (schema+vocab re-verified read-only; OD-W9 title/body derivability
    resolved via source_span + pinned region; OD-W8 enacted/open flagged for governance
    confirmation only). If accepted, NO vocab seed needed ⇒ W-2 drops; track = W-1→W-3→W-4→W-5.
  writer code-authoring brief (doc 4) + verification/rollback plan (doc 5) authored —
    enough for a separately-gated W-3 phase to build a DB-isolated birth-gate writer.

2. Macro-goal questions answered

repo/branch/HEAD: /Users/nmhuyen/iu-cutter-build/repo/iu-cutter · feature/constitution-
  snapshot-mark-dryrun · d66a60d (unchanged); working tree clean before+after
cutplan/test sha: byte-exact (548eabc5… / 06e871e7…); tests not re-run this phase (no code
  change; the cut-plan RUN itself exercises cutplan end-to-end and PASSED)
input manifest/digest/count: regenerated; file sha 7d56f3ce…, digest 9d908a62…, 60/4
cut-plan run: RAN (safe, net-zero, no DB) — not just command-review
artifacts/digest/report: doc 2 (5 artifacts + sha256 + cut_plan_digest edcae74f…)
NGUYEN_TAC/KIEN_TRUC IU-or-container: PROPOSED all-IU (keeps 60 + reconstruction) — OD-W1
DIEU unit_kind: PROPOSED law_unit (vocab present, no seed) — OD-W2
parent/container: parent_or_container_ref by address path; NULL top-level; no synthetic
  root (count stays 60) — OD-W3
canonical_address: VERBATIM (N-4) — OD-W4
idempotency/collision: OD-1 key + pre-existence check + UNIQUE backstop + G-CUT-ONCE — OD-W5
vocab dot_config seed: NONE needed under recommended mapping (all keys re-verified) — OD-W6
signing/credential: DB-isolated writer first (W-3), credential/signing at W-4, prod W-5 — OD-W7
verification after writer: VW-1..VW-10 (doc 5)
rollback/compensation: append-only forward-compensation; atomic all-or-nothing (doc 5)
writer code-authoring scope: doc 4 (cutwrite.py DB-isolated + scratch birth-gate dry-run)
missing_evidence: NONE (OD-W8 is a governance confirmation, not a code unknown)

3. Quality gates

QG1 cut-plan dry-run readiness + N-1 sha-verify           : PASS (doc 1)
QG2 cut-plan RUN net-zero, artifact-only, PASS            : PASS (doc 1/2)
QG3 cut-plan artifacts + digests captured                  : PASS (doc 2)
QG4 OD-W1..OD-W9 rulings proposed w/ reason                 : PASS (doc 3)
QG5 minimal cut-plan-row → IU+unit_version mapping          : PASS (doc 4)
QG6 birth-gate txn + idempotency/collision contract         : PASS (doc 4)
QG7 verification + rollback/compensation doctrine           : PASS (doc 5)
QG8 writer code-authoring scope for next phase              : PASS (doc 4)
QG9 no production mutation / no invented prod command       : PASS (§4)
QG10 STOP after upload, route GPT/User                      : PASS (§5)

4. Explicit no-mutation statement

production_mutation: NONE. No production DB/IU/Directus/vector write · no CUT · no VERIFY ·
  no source/version mutation · no deploy/restart · no merge/push/tag · no writer code
  authored · no invented production writer command · no self-advance.
actions_performed: deterministic manifest regen + cut-plan dry-run in EPHEMERAL /tmp
  (shredded) using only committed ratified code, all DB env unset; read-only PG schema/
  vocab re-verification; 6 KB documents created (folder was empty pre-author). Repo
  unchanged (HEAD d66a60d, tree clean).

5. Disposition — STOP → route GPT/User

result: CUTPLAN_DRYRUN_PASS__WRITER_AUTHORING_BRIEF_READY
kb_path: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-cutplan-dryrun-and-writer-decision-package/
docs: [cutplan-dryrun-readiness-and-result(1), cutplan-artifact-and-digest(2),
       writer-od-rulings-proposal(3), writer-code-authoring-brief(4),
       writer-verification-and-rollback-plan(5), macro-task-closeout-report(6)]
decisions_required_from_GPT_User (each its own gate; NOT self-advanced):
  - ratify OD-W1..OD-W9 (doc 3) — esp. OD-W1 all-IU, OD-W2 law_unit, OD-W8 enacted/open
  - authorize W-3: design→author→CI→commit a DB-isolated cutwrite writer + scratch
    birth-gate dry-run (feature branch only; no production)
  - W-4 cutter_exec/cutter_verify credential + DOT-991/992 signing cycle (separate)
  - W-5 production CUT command-review + SEPARATE explicit production-DB-write approval
  - (optional) accept the cut-plan PASS evidence as the ratified first cut-plan dry-run
forbidden_and_not_performed: production CUT/VERIFY · production DB/IU write · deploy/restart
  · merge/push/tag · source/version mutation · invented production command · self-advance.
next_action: STOP. Route to GPT/User for the OD-W ratification + W-3 authorization.

doc 6 of 6. No production mutation. Self-advance PROHIBITED.