dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Status-Marker Amendment Authoring Report

Phase: v0_5_constitution_status_marker_amendment_authoring · Nature: DML_authoring_only / no_execution · Date: 2026-05-18 Decision authority: GPT / User ONLY · Self-advance: PROHIBITED

1. Executive summary

objective: author DML + rollback + verification + report to add the 2 missing
  status markers to live grammar_profile incomex-architecture-constitution-v4:
    "📝" -> draft
    "⛔" -> obsolete
authority: GPT ruling R1 = APPROVE_SM_OPT_1_AMEND_PROFILE_MAP_4 (classification
  mapping only; does NOT make draft/obsolete cut-eligible).
result: 4-document authoring package complete. NO DML executed. NO dry-run.
  NO source_document seed. NO CUT/VERIFY.
package_status: READY_FOR_GPT_COMMAND_REVIEW
production_state_at_authoring: UNCHANGED (read-only KB grounding only)

2. What was read (grounding; no production mutation)

read:
  - reviews/dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-constitution-fixture-ratification-gpt-ruling-2026-05-18.md
      -> R1 amend-map-4 (mapping only); R2 first dry-run enacted_only; R3 defer
         Điều 44; R4 authority sufficient; R5 leaf rule; B1 still blocking until
         DML amendment authored/reviewed/executed; next_phase = THIS phase.
  - v0.5-constitution-fixture-source-grammar-ratification/ (5 docs)
      -> grammar-applicability: levels PASS, marker coverage FAIL_PARTIAL,
         AMD-SM1 required; status-marker-and-scope-ruling-request; source_
         document/version identity plan (LIVE schema leaner; Nuxt platform).
  - reviews/dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-WS-Q5-seed-privilege-production-closeout-gpt-review-2026-05-18.md
      -> WS-Q5 CLOSED_PASS_LIVE; grammar_profile_status_marker = 2 live rows.
  - v0.5-ws-q5-seed-privilege-production-execution/ (3 docs)
      -> verification SMV-2: live ✅=e29c85 enacted, 📋=f09f938b controlled_draft;
         SYSID 7611578671664259111 unchanged; catalog/codepoint method mandated.
  - v0.5-ws-q5-seed-privilege-revised-command-package/ (seed-data §5, seed-rollback)
      -> live table = (grammar_profile_ref, marker, maps_to); NO lifecycle column
         on this thin mapping table; existing INSERT house style.
grounding_conflicts_found: NONE. Live schema, production state, and the latest
  GPT ruling are mutually consistent with this authoring scope.

3. What was authored (this package — 4 files)

files:
  1 dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-constitution-status-marker-amendment-DML-draft-2026-05-18.sql.md
      guarded INSERT ... SELECT FROM live grammar_profile; +2 rows (📝→draft,
      ⛔→obsolete); NOT EXISTS self-guard; exact UTF-8; no UPDATE/DELETE/ON
      CONFLICT; ✅/📋 never targeted. + informational plain-VALUES equivalent.
  2 dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-constitution-status-marker-amendment-rollback-draft-2026-05-18.sql.md
      PATH_R-A exact 2-row scoped DELETE (marker+maps_to predicate, no CASCADE);
      PATH_R-B (lifecycle-retire) documented NOT APPLICABLE (no lifecycle col);
      PATH_R-C supersede+escalate on pre-probe failure.
  3 dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-constitution-status-marker-amendment-verification-plan-2026-05-18.md
      PRE-1..7 / POST-1..9 / NEG-1..6; hex-codepoint assertions; proves 4
      mappings, no dup, no unintended profile, ✅/📋 preserved, scope frozen.
  4 dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-constitution-status-marker-amendment-authoring-report-2026-05-18.md
      this report.
codepoints_locked:
  ✅ U+2705 e29c85 | 📋 U+1F4CB f09f938b | 📝 U+1F4DD f09f939d | ⛔ U+26D4 e29b94

4. Quality-gate self-assessment

QG1 DML adds exactly 2 marker rows ...................... PASS
QG2 no execution occurred ............................... PASS (authoring only)
QG3 UTF-8 marker codepoints preserved ................... PASS (hex-asserted)
QG4 existing ✅ and 📋 rows preserved ................... PASS (never targeted)
QG5 draft/obsolete remain non-cut-eligible .............. PASS (classification
     only; NEG-1..3 freeze scope/policy; enacted_only intact)
QG6 verification proves 4 mappings + no duplicates ...... PASS (POST-2/POST-5)
QG7 report states ready/not-ready for command-review .... PASS (READY — §1/§6)
QG8 stop after uploading 4 files ........................ PASS (stopping now)

5. Ready for GPT command-review?

ready_for_gpt_command_review: YES
rationale:
  - scope is exactly GPT ruling R1 (mapping-only, +2 rows), no scope creep
  - schema-accurate to LIVE (3-col table, no lifecycle), production-grounded
  - rollback is exact-inverse, scoped, no CASCADE; non-destructive fallbacks
  - verification proves all 4 mappings codepoint-exact + preservation + no dup
  - all forbidden items respected; nothing executed
blocker_disposition:
  B1 (status-marker amendment) -> DML/rollback/verification AUTHORED; remains
     blocking only on GPT command-review + (later, separate) execution gate.

6. Open decisions remaining (NOT self-resolved — flagged for GPT/User)

OD-A source_document seed (B5): source_document_registry /
  source_document_version_registry still 0 rows. Identity plan exists
  (…constitution-source-document-version-plan…) but seed authoring is a
  SEPARATE later sovereign-gated phase. NOT in this package.
OD-B Nuxt parser / checksum determinism (B6): platform is Nuxt SPA (MISMATCH-1).
  content_checksum normalize/strip_chrome ruleset (parser_profile, OD-SR2) is
  unresolved; belongs to source_document/version seed or dry-run package. NOT
  decided here.
OD-C Constitution dry-run package: NOT authored, NOT authorized. First dry-run
  scope fixed by ruling R2 = enacted_only (✅ only); 📋/📝/⛔ excluded;
  controlled-draft Điều 44 deferred (R3). Sequenced AFTER marker amendment
  execution + source_document seed.
OD-D leaf-IU granularity (R5) applies to the future dry-run, not this phase.
none_self_resolved: all flagged as GPT/User decisions; Agent took no decision.

7. Explicit no-execution & repo-access statement

no_dml_executed: TRUE
statements:
  - No INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE executed. No source_document(_version) INSERT.
  - No Constitution dry-run, no CUT, no VERIFY.
  - No schema change, no GRANT/REVOKE, no index DDL, no Directus mutation,
    no vector/NoSQL, no deploy/restart.
  - No git commit. Output is KB documents only (Agent Data upload).
repo_access_note: |
  Session working dir is NOT a git repository (git=false); there is no local
  repo checkout. All inputs were read read-only from Agent Data KB and all 4
  outputs were written to Agent Data KB under
  knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-constitution-status-marker-amendment-authoring/.
  No filesystem/repo writes, no commits — consistent with the forbidden list.

8. Routing

status: STATUS_MARKER_AMENDMENT_AUTHORING_COMPLETE__READY_FOR_GPT_COMMAND_REVIEW
next_action: route to GPT / User for command-review of the DML + rollback +
  verification plan. Execution remains a SEPARATE, later, sovereign-gated step.
self_advance: PROHIBITED — STOP after this 4-file package.

Companion: status-marker-amendment-DML-draft, status-marker-amendment-rollback-draft, status-marker-amendment-verification-plan.