dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Source Snapshot Capture E1 Verification Result

Phase: v0_5_constitution_source_snapshot_capture_e1_execution · Date: 2026-05-18 · doc 2 of 3 Status: BLOCKED (SC3) · method = catalog/codepoint assertions, no rendered-string equality

artifact_written: false ; mutation: none ; decision_authority: GPT / User ONLY
self_advance: PROHIBITED

1. Verification checks

check                                                      expected   observed                       status
SNAP-1  snapshot artifact exists exactly once              =1         0 (none written; SC3 pre-write) NOT_MET (by design — blocked)
SNAP-2  path first16 == metadata checksum prefix           exact      N/A (no artifact)               N/A
SNAP-3  metadata checksum == region rehash                 exact      N/A (no artifact)               N/A
SNAP-4  normalized-content region rehash                   PASS       N/A (no artifact)               N/A
SNAP-5  marker counts == 19/1/1/1 (codepoint-exact)        19/1/1/1   19/1/1/1                        PASS (on computed content)
SNAP-6  no second artifact same prefix diff checksum       none       none (dir empty)                PASS
SNAP-7  raw_fetch_checksum != content_checksum             true       n/a (no artifact; raw forensic) N/A
GATE-X  computed checksum == ratified canonical            equal      072983ac… vs 17660443…          FAIL -> SC3
GATE-Y  computed length == ratified canonical              17522      17657 (Δ +135)                  FAIL -> SC3
GATE-Z  3-fetch normalized stability (this environment)    stable     072983ac… ×3                    PASS

2. No-overwrite / no-mutation assertions

no_overwrite_occurred: TRUE  (nothing written; snapshot dir was empty)
no_delete_occurred:    TRUE
no_source_document_insert:         TRUE
no_source_document_version_insert: TRUE
no_DML_executed:                   TRUE
no_production_db_mutation:         TRUE
no_checksum_persisted_into_registry: TRUE
no_dry_run / no_CUT / no_VERIFY:   TRUE
no_schema_change / no_GRANT_REVOKE / no_index_DDL: TRUE
no_directus_mutation / no_deploy_restart / no_git_commit: TRUE
no_self_advance_to_E2: TRUE
kb_writes_this_phase: 3 (E1 execution-log, this verification-result, report) only

3. Interpretation

markers_19_1_1_1: PASS — consistent with the ratified Constitution family
  state; the source is structurally the same document (no marker drift).
identity_divergence: the environment's faithful application of the documented
  profile yields 072983ac…/17657, deterministically (3/3), but this is NOT the
  ratified canonical nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 identity
  (17660443…/17522). A snapshot frozen from a non-canonical parser would be
  internally self-consistent yet externally WRONG, breaking the ratification
  chain that B6/Option-B exist to protect.
conclusion: correct action = BLOCKED, no artifact, escalate (SC3).

4. Statement

• Only read-only E1 capture/measure performed (QG1); no DML/seed/dry-run/CUT/VERIFY (QG2); no artifact written so no checksum-addressed path created (QG3 N/A by block); no overwrite (QG4); marker counts 19/1/1/1 PASS but canonical-identity gate FAIL → SC3; no rehash possible (QG6 N/A by block, integrity preserved by NOT writing). Nothing mutated.
• doc 2 of 3; STOP after 3 files → route GPT/User. Self-advance PROHIBITED.

Companions: capture-execution-log, capture-report.