dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Source Snapshot Capture E1 Report

Phase: v0_5_constitution_source_snapshot_capture_e1_execution · Date: 2026-05-18 · doc 3 of 3

decision_authority: GPT / User ONLY ; self_advance: PROHIBITED

1. Result fields

capture_status: BLOCKED          # PASS | BLOCKED | ALREADY_EXISTS_SAME_CONTENT | FAIL
blocker: SC3_parser_profile_reproduction_divergence
source_url: https://vps.incomexsaigoncorp.vn/knowledge/dev/laws/constitution
parser_profile_ref: nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 (specified; applied via
  prose-spec reconstruction in Claude CLI — NOT the ratified canonical executor)
snapshot_artifact_path: NOT_CREATED
  would_be_if_canonical: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/snapshots/
    constitution/constitution-normalized-17660443e0f23e99.md
  computed_noncanonical:  …/constitution-normalized-072983ac6cf44ee0.md (NOT created)
normalized_content_checksum:
  computed_this_env: 072983ac6cf44ee0722d0fff68731135a00f224db459bc43e51d1c0c31b3bdea
  ratified_canonical: 17660443e0f23e994e1807cf8e22920951a9e70c598956dbd0e752f4f5cae80c
  match: FALSE
normalized_content_length:
  computed_this_env: 17657 ; ratified_canonical: 17522 ; delta: +135
marker_counts: {enacted:19, controlled_draft:1, draft:1, obsolete:1}  # == expected
metadata_summary: NOT_APPLICABLE — no artifact written
readback_rehash_result: NOT_APPLICABLE — no artifact written
collision_check_result: snapshot dir empty; NO pre-existing artifact; NO collision
  (no overwrite/delete attempted or possible)
downstream_not_executed:
  source_document_insert: false ; source_document_version_insert: false
  dml: false ; production_db_mutation: false ; checksum_persisted_into_registry: false
  dry_run: false ; cut: false ; verify: false ; schema_change: false
  grant_revoke: false ; directus_mutation: false ; deploy_restart: false
  git_commit: false ; self_advance_to_E2: false ; artifact_written: false

2. Why BLOCKED (root cause)

finding: this environment's faithful application of parser_profile
  nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 (documented N1..N6 + candidate_B span)
  yields a DETERMINISTIC but NON-CANONICAL identity (072983ac…/17657, stable
  3/3), Δ +135 chars vs the ratified canonical (17660443…/17522). This exactly
  reproduces the 2026-05-18 drift-triage reconstruction divergence.
why_not_write: freezing 072983ac… while stamping parser_profile_ref
  nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 would (a) mislabel a non-canonical parser
  output as the ratified profile, and (b) pin an identity into E2's
  source_document_version that NO ratified process ever produced — silently
  corrupting the very ratification chain Option B exists to protect.
  Per governance (KB SSOT; fail-closed; no-silent; never invent missing
  authority) the only correct action is STOP_AND_ESCALATE without writing.
markers_ok: 19/1/1/1 — the source is structurally the same Constitution family
  (no marker-structure drift); the divergence is parser-implementation, not a
  changed normative document.
confound_flagged: raw bytes today ≈1,213,388 vs Codex 2026-05-18 ≈1,205,114
  (+~8.2KB). Cannot disambiguate "live page drifted again" from
  "reconstruction ≠ canonical" using a non-canonical parser. Both push toward
  escalation, not freezing.

3. Next recommended phase (decision is GPT/User — not taken here)

recommended: GPT/User ruling on the canonical-parser execution surface for E1.
options_for_GPT (not self-selected):
  R1 CANONICAL_EXECUTOR_RUNS_E1: re-run E1 on the authoritative VPS/Codex
     environment that produced the ratified 17660443…/17522 under B6, so the
     frozen artifact's region-hash IS the ratified canonical identity. (Most
     aligned with B6/Option-B chain; recommended.)
  R2 RATIFY_REFERENCE_IMPLEMENTATION: GPT ratifies a single portable, byte-exact
     reference implementation of nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 (publishable
     to KB) so any approved executor reproduces the canonical identity. Removes
     the environment-divergence class permanently.
  R3 RE-RATIFY_CURRENT_CONTENT: if R1's canonical executor also no longer yields
     17660443…/17522 (live page drifted again — see §2 confound), treat as a new
     living-drift event: re-run the B6-style cross-interval determinism on the
     CURRENT content with the canonical executor, GPT re-ratifies the new
     canonical checksum, THEN E1 freezes that.
forbidden_regardless: writing/freezing the non-canonical 072983ac… artifact;
  retrying old f9d22d05…; silent checksum update; seeding from unpinned/non-
  canonical content; self-advance to E2.
B5_status: OPEN/BLOCKED (E1 did not produce a usable pinned artifact)

4. Git / repo access note

repo_files_created: 0 (no application code, no DML file, no local artifact)
git_commit_created: false
kb_uploads_this_phase: 3 (E1 execution-log, verification-result, this report)
artifact_in_kb_snapshots: NONE
scratch: local /tmp only, deleted after measurement; no secrets recorded

5. Statement

• Only E1 read-only capture/measure executed (QG1); no DML/seed/dry-run/CUT/VERIFY (QG2); no artifact written so no checksum-addressed path created (QG3 — block precedes write); no overwrite/delete (QG4); markers 19/1/1/1 PASS but canonical-identity gate FAIL → SC3 (QG5/QG6 integrity preserved by refusing to freeze a non-canonical artifact); report carries next-recommended-phase (QG7); 3 files then STOP (QG8).
• doc 3 of 3; capture_status = BLOCKED; STOP → route GPT/User. Self-advance PROHIBITED.

Companions: capture-execution-log, capture-verification-result.