dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Source Snapshot Capture E1 Execution Log

Phase: v0_5_constitution_source_snapshot_capture_e1_execution · Date: 2026-05-18 · doc 1 of 3 Executor: Claude Code CLI · Status: BLOCKED · Stop condition: SC3_parser_profile_reproduction_divergence

e1_scope_only: true ; artifact_written: false ; dml: none ; seed: none
dry_run/cut/verify: none ; checksum_persisted_into_registry: NONE
mutation: none (KB read-only + 3 E1 report uploads only) ; secrets: none
decision_authority: GPT / User ONLY ; self_advance: PROHIBITED

0. Authority

read_before (KB-SSOT, read-only):
  - reviews/…source-snapshot-capture-authoring-command-review-and-e1-approval-2026-05-18
    (PASS_FOR_E1_CONTROLLED_CAPTURE; O1..O6 ruled; E1 actions enumerated)
  - v0.5-constitution-source-snapshot-capture-authoring/ (artifact-spec, procedure-draft)
  - reviews/…source-snapshot-version-policy-gpt-ruling-2026-05-18 (Option B)
  - reviews/…checksum-drift-triage-gpt-ruling-2026-05-18 (REAL_SOURCE_CHANGE)
canonical_reference (ratified, KB-SSOT): parser_profile nuxt-incomex-portal-
  constitution-v1 -> normalized_content_checksum
  17660443e0f23e994e1807cf8e22920951a9e70c598956dbd0e752f4f5cae80c / len 17522 /
  markers ✅19 📋1 📝1 ⛔1 (Codex BLOCKED execution log + drift-triage ruling)

1. CP-1 source fetch result (read-only, 3×)

source_url: https://vps.incomexsaigoncorp.vn/knowledge/dev/laws/constitution
method: GET x3, read-only, no redirects followed by tool
fetch1: http=200 bytes=1213388 time=6.12s raw_sha256=95d4db4e62c354f9fb36c1e45964eb1786203e522ec448ea30e5116d53e43cd9
fetch2: http=200 bytes=1213250 time=6.44s raw_sha256=36cd832078e92987b85e333d0142ed3fe8635c21f9c6101b834022062c4d825d
fetch3: http=200 bytes=1213250 time=5.14s raw_sha256=03bcfb98d59a82a0e400b97d52aa8960c9c3837440502092dfe27fd43015fad8
raw_drift: YES across the 3 fetches — FORENSIC ONLY (expected Nuxt render noise, B6 CLOSED)
forensic_note: raw bytes ~1,213,388 today vs Codex 2026-05-18 raw 1,205,114
  (≈ +8,200 bytes) — possible additional live drift since the ratified capture,
  OR Nuxt render-noise band; cannot be disambiguated with a non-canonical parser
article_elements_found: 1 (deterministic extraction anchor)

2. CP-2 parser profile applied

parser_profile_ref: nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 (as specified)
extraction: first server-rendered <article>; <script>/<style> subtrees dropped
normalization: N1 HTML-unescape; N2 NFC; N3 CRLF/CR->LF;
  N4 collapse [ \t\f\v]+ -> space; N5 trim line ends; N6 collapse blank-line runs
authoritative_span: candidate_B (H1 "HIẾN PHÁP" -> end CHANGELOG, EXCL trailing
  "Back to Knowledge Hub" backlink); CHANGELOG INCLUDED
implementation_caveat: this profile was applied via a PROSE-SPEC RECONSTRUCTION
  in the Claude CLI environment. The ratified canonical implementation is the
  one executed on the VPS/Codex environment (which produced 17660443…/17522).
  No canonical reference implementation of the profile is stored in KB.

3. CP-3 measured result (3-fetch stability)

fetch1: norm_len=17657 norm_sha256=072983ac6cf44ee0722d0fff68731135a00f224db459bc43e51d1c0c31b3bdea markers={enacted:19,controlled_draft:1,draft:1,obsolete:1}
fetch2: norm_len=17657 norm_sha256=072983ac6cf44ee0722d0fff68731135a00f224db459bc43e51d1c0c31b3bdea markers={enacted:19,controlled_draft:1,draft:1,obsolete:1}
fetch3: norm_len=17657 norm_sha256=072983ac6cf44ee0722d0fff68731135a00f224db459bc43e51d1c0c31b3bdea markers={enacted:19,controlled_draft:1,draft:1,obsolete:1}
3_fetch_normalized_stable: TRUE (deterministic in this environment, 3/3)
computed_normalized_content_checksum: 072983ac6cf44ee0722d0fff68731135a00f224db459bc43e51d1c0c31b3bdea
computed_normalized_content_length:   17657
computed_marker_counts:               {enacted:19, controlled_draft:1, draft:1, obsolete:1}

4. Gate evaluation

G_marker_counts_19_1_1_1:           PASS  (19/1/1/1 codepoint-exact)
G_3_fetch_normalized_stable:        PASS  (072983ac… ×3)
G_checksum_eq_ratified_canonical:   FAIL  (072983ac… ≠ ratified 17660443…)
G_length_eq_ratified_canonical:     FAIL  (17657 ≠ 17522 ; Δ +135)
classification: parser-profile reproduction DIVERGENCE — the environment's
  faithful application of the documented profile does NOT reproduce the
  ratified canonical normalized identity. Identical to the 2026-05-18
  drift-triage divergence (17657/072983ac…), now confirmed deterministic 3/3.
stop_condition_triggered: SC3 (parser_profile reproduction failure)

5. CP-4/CP-5 path derivation + collision check (read-only)

note: path derivation is MOOT — the computed checksum is NON-CANONICAL, so no
  legitimate artifact can be addressed by it under parser_profile_ref
  nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1.
snapshot_root_listed (read-only): knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/snapshots/constitution/
  -> items: 0 (directory empty; NO pre-existing artifact; NO collision)
would_be_path_if_canonical: constitution-normalized-17660443e0f23e99.md (NOT created)
computed_nonecanonical_path: constitution-normalized-072983ac6cf44ee0.md (NOT created)

6. CP-6 write result

artifact_written: FALSE
reason: SC3 — refusing to freeze a non-canonical parser output mislabeled as
  parser_profile_ref nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1. Writing it would
  poison the E2 source_document_version identity with a checksum no ratified
  process ever produced. Fail-closed; no-silent; never invent authority.
overwrite_attempted: FALSE ; delete_attempted: FALSE

7. CP-7 readback / rehash result

performed: N/A — no artifact written, nothing to re-read or rehash

8. Secrets / mutation statement

secrets_recorded: none (no tokens/cookies/IPs/headers)
mutation: none — no artifact write, no source_document/version INSERT, no DML,
  no production DB mutation, no checksum persisted into registry, no dry-run,
  no CUT, no VERIFY, no schema/GRANT/index change, no Directus mutation, no
  deploy/restart, no git commit. KB: read-only grounding + 3 E1 report uploads.
scratch: local /tmp temp files, deleted after measurement.

9. Execution status

execution_status: BLOCKED
blocker: SC3_parser_profile_reproduction_divergence
artifact_written: false ; self_advance: prohibited ; route: GPT/User review

Companions: capture-verification-result, capture-report.