dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Nuxt Cross-Interval Confirmation Report

Phase: v0_5_constitution_nuxt_checksum_cross_interval_confirmation · Date: 2026-05-18 · doc 3 of 3

package_status: AUTHORED ; B6_recommendation: CLOSED
dml_executed: 0 ; source_seed: 0 ; dry_run: none ; cut: none ; verify: none
decision_authority: GPT / User ONLY ; self_advance: PROHIBITED

1. Executive summary

GPT downgraded B6 to PARTIAL and required exactly one cross-interval / separate-session confirmation of the approved-in-principle profile nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1. This phase performed that confirmation in a separate session ~15 minutes later. The raw Nuxt response drifted again (intra-session and across the interval), but the normalized authoritative-content checksum, normalized length, and status-marker counts were an exact MATCH to the prior candidate across all 3 fetches. The GPT-stated confirmation condition is fully met. Recommendation: B6 CLOSED, return to Constitution source_document/source_version seed authoring. Nothing seeded or executed.

2. What was read (KB, read-only)

read_full:
  - reviews/…constitution-nuxt-parser-checksum-ratification-gpt-ruling-2026-05-18 (AUTHORITATIVE latest)
  - v0.5-constitution-nuxt-parser-checksum-ratification/ (all 5: operational-framing,
    grounding-and-repeatability, extraction+normalization-design, parser-profile+ruling-request, report)
  - reviews/…constitution-source-document-seed-authoring-gpt-review-2026-05-18
  - handoffs/dot-iu-cutter-current-operating-objectives-and-principles-2026-05-18
kb_state: consistent ; no missing path ; output dir was empty (no prior collision)
conflict_with_latest_gpt_ruling: none
production_state_vs_stated_facts: consistent (source_document=0, source_document_version=0
  per seed-authoring review; B1 CLOSED; B5 OPEN; B6 PARTIAL pre-this-phase)
authority_basis: KB only (latest GPT ruling); prior-session memory NOT used as authority

3. What was tested (read-only, this session)

method: 3x read-only HTTP GET, redirects=0, separate session @ 2026-05-18T09:17Z
  (ratification-phase window was ~09:02–09:03Z) ; bytes+headers hashed in local
  /tmp scratch, deleted after ; profile nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1 applied
  verbatim (no new normalization rule invented)
transport: HTTP 200 x3 ; text/html;charset=utf-8 ; nginx/1.29.5 ; x-powered-by Nuxt ; cache-control no-cache

4. Result

raw_fetch_checksum: UNSTABLE — fetch1=fetch3 08031d54…b21079, fetch2 5b04f09e…5aaa09;
  sizes 1,199,873 / 1,199,962 ; also differ from prior phase (1,197,088 / 1,196,999)
  -> harmless Nuxt render noise (forensic-only), confirmed across interval
normalized candidate_B (authoritative span, CHANGELOG included):
  len 17791 ; sha256 f9d22d0571fa296cbc8e308c46acde93804ffcfb4a19a2e7f55dabd8657d1689
  -> MATCH prior candidate, identical across all 3 fetches
normalized candidate_A (inclusive): len 18127 ; sha256 d94a977d…b231 -> MATCH prior, 3/3
status_markers: ✅19 📋1 📝1 ⛔1 -> MATCH 19/1/1/1, 3/3, codepoint-exact
drift_classification: NOT real content change ; NOT normalization instability ;
  NOT fetch/tool issue -> only harmless raw Nuxt churn
combined_evidence: 6 independent fetches across 2 sessions — normalized identical
  every time, raw different every time

5. B6 status recommendation

B6_Nuxt_parser_checksum_determinism: RECOMMEND CLOSED
  - GPT's single remaining evidence gate (one cross-interval/separate-session
    confirmation) is satisfied with exact MATCH on checksum + length + markers
  - R-OD-SR2 (span), R-CL1 (CHANGELOG include), R-PP1 (profile-ref storage, no
    schema change) already ruled by GPT; only R-B6 closure remained
canonical content_checksum candidate (persist ONLY in a future gated seed cmd-review):
  f9d22d0571fa296cbc8e308c46acde93804ffcfb4a19a2e7f55dabd8657d1689 (len 17791)
NOT updated this phase (no real content change; no silent canonical update)
conservatism option: GPT MAY still hold PARTIAL for one post-Nuxt-deploy check;
  Agent assesses the stated requirement as fully met -> CLOSED recommended

6. Ready to return to source_document seed authoring?

ready_pending_GPT_B6_CLOSED_ruling: YES
on_B6_CLOSED:
  next_phase: v0_5_constitution_source_document_seed_authoring (RESTART)
  nature: authoring_only__no_execution
  fill: NO-DML-DRAFT placeholders under nuxt-incomex-portal-constitution-v1
        (content_checksum f9d22d05…d1689 ; document_version_id deterministic;
         provenance carries raw_checksum + parser_profile_ref per R-PP1)
  unchanged constraints: source_document + source_document_version ATOMIC ;
    enacted_only first dry-run ; controlled-draft Điều 44 deferred ;
    no parser_profile table / no schema change (R-PP1)
do_not (this phase authorizes none of): source seed INSERT, dry-run, CUT, VERIFY,
  command-review, self-advance

7. Open decisions (for GPT / User)

R-B6-CLOSE: confirm B6 CLOSED (Agent recommendation) vs hold PARTIAL for one
  post-deploy re-confirmation
on_close: authorize restart of source_document/source_version seed authoring
  (authoring-only; execution remains separately gated)

8. Explicit no-execution + access statement

no_source_document_INSERT: true ; no source_document_version_INSERT: true ;
no_DML: true ; no_Constitution_dry_run: true ; no_CUT: true ; no_VERIFY: true ;
no_schema_change: true ; no_GRANT_REVOKE: true ; no_index_DDL: true ;
no_Directus_mutation: true ; no_vector_NoSQL: true ; no_deploy_restart: true ;
no_git_commit: true ; no_checksum_persisted: true ; canonical_checksum_unchanged: true ;
self_advance: PROHIBITED
git_repo_access: none — primary working dir is not a git repository; no VPS/repo
  shell. KB is SSOT via Agent Data (read + 3 uploads only). Source contacted only
  by 3 read-only HTTP GET from the local session; bytes hashed in local /tmp
  scratch then deleted; no secrets recorded. Live production facts taken from
  read-only KB records (no catalog SELECT this session).
files_uploaded: 3 (this package) -> STOP -> route GPT/User

9. Statement

• Same approved-in-principle profile reproduced exactly (QG1); source grounded read-only x3 in a separate session/interval (QG2); normalized checksum compared to prior candidate = MATCH (QG3); marker counts compared = MATCH 19/1/1/1 (QG4); raw Nuxt drift distinguished from normalized content drift (QG5); clear B6 recommendation = CLOSED (QG6); no source seed/DML/dry-run/CUT/VERIFY (QG7); 3 files then STOP (QG8).
• doc 3 of 3; package complete; STOP → route GPT/User. Self-advance PROHIBITED.

Companion: cross-interval-fetch-and-normalization-result, cross-interval-B6-ruling-request.