dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Source/Grammar Ratification Readiness Report

Phase: v0_5_constitution_fixture_source_grammar_ratification · Nature: read_only_grounding_plus_design_authoring__no_execution · Date: 2026-05-18 Authority consumed (NOT reopened): GPT OD-SF1 ruling 2026-05-18.

1. Executive summary

The internal Incomex Architecture Constitution fixture was re-grounded read-only (HTTP 200; title Hiến pháp Kiến trúc Hệ thống Incomex v4.6.3 BAN HÀNH). Its 3-level hierarchy matches the ratified grammar profile incomex-architecture-constitution-v4, and the locked BR-A1 address scheme is expressible for every node. However, source/grammar ratification is NOT yet complete: the fixture uses 4 status markers while the profile maps only 2, so a grammar status-marker amendment is required before any Constitution dry-run. Verdict: PASS_WITH_BLOCKERS — ratification readiness gated on GPT/User rulings R1–R5 and a later amendment + source-seed gate. No mutation, no cut, no dry-run, no source_document insert performed.

2. What was read

kb_read:
  - reviews/…deferred-source-family-grammar-binding-gpt-ruling (OD-SF1, latest authority)
  - reviews/…WS-Q5-seed-privilege-production-closeout-gpt-review
  - v0.5-ws-q5-seed-privilege-production-execution/ (prior phase context)
  - WS-2 source-family-grammar-authority (D2/D3/D4), WS-2 entity-registry (D5/D6)
  - WS-3 cross-source logical proof (Constitution role context)
  - v0.5-constitution-hardtest-design/: master-plan, canonicalization & address
    grammar, source-document ingestion pipeline (checksum/versioning grounding)
source_grounding: one read-only HTTP GET of the registered source URL (VPS)
production_readonly: catalog SELECT — grammar_profile / levels / status_markers /
  address_template / source_family / source_document(_version) schema + 0 rows

3. What was found

identity: internal Incomex Architecture Constitution v4.6.3 BAN HÀNH (confirmed;
  NOT national 2013). KB-7294/rev44 not surfaced in rendered HTML (FLAG-4).
hierarchy: NGUYEN_TAC (15 Nguyên tắc) / KIEN_TRUC_SECTION (A·B·C) / DIEU
  (Mục lục Luật 0..44) — exactly matches ratified profile levels (PASS).
markers: ✅(38) 📋(2) ratified-mapped; 📝(draft) ⛔(obsolete) observed but
  NOT mapped -> grammar amendment AMD-SM1 required (BLOCKER).
platform: Nuxt (was Directus in prior KB) -> parser_profile/noise-strip impact.
drift: CHANGELOG to 2026-05-18 (was 2026-04-18) -> content_checksum identity.
schema: live source_document(_version) leaner than 2026-05-17 design proposal
  (no raw_checksum / grammar_profile_ref / expected_format cols) -> plan adapted.
production_state: sysid 7611578671664259111; grammar profile + source_family +
  address template LIVE; source_document_registry/version = 0 rows (matches the
  stated current live facts; no mismatch; no conflict with latest GPT ruling).

4. Is source/grammar ratification ready?

ratification_status: PASS_WITH_BLOCKERS — NOT yet ratified, NOT dry-run ready
level_grammar: READY (3 levels match; no amendment)
address_scheme: READY (BR-A1 locked; expressible; encodes_status=false)
status_marker_grammar: NOT READY (needs AMD-SM1 amendment, ruling-gated)
source_identity_plan: READY-AS-DESIGN (deterministic, schema-accurate, not executed)
overall: a ratification PACKAGE is prepared; ratification itself awaits GPT/User
  rulings (R1–R5) + a separate amendment + source-seed gate.

5. Blockers vs non-blockers (QG7)

BLOCKERS (must resolve before Constitution dry-run):
  B1 grammar status-marker amendment AMD-SM1 (📝/⛔) — ruling R1, then a
     separate authoring→command-review→execution DML gate
  B2 first-dry-run scope ruling R2 (recommend enacted_only) + R3 (defer Điều 44)
  B3 OD-S1 (R4): authority sufficiency / enacted_only confirmation
  B4 OD-G2 (R5): leaf-IU granularity (Điều vs sub-bullet) — gates volume/+15
  B5 source_document + source_document_version seed AUTHORING package
     (separate gate, after B1–B4) — currently 0 rows, none authored
  B6 parser_profile for Nuxt-rendered HTML (noise-strip / OD-SR2 checksum
     normalization ruleset) — gates content_checksum determinism

NON-BLOCKERS (do not block ratification; tracked):
  N1 source_family / grammar_profile / address_template already LIVE
  N2 BR-A1 docprefix scheme locked; ICX-CONST recommended
  N3 OD-SF1 does NOT block Constitution (GPT ruling confirmed)
  N4 living-document drift — handled by content_checksum versioning design
  N5 source_span physicalization — downstream Q5/Q6 ingestion gate (design-only)

6. Recommended next step (recommend, NOT self-advanced)

next_action: GPT/User review of THIS ratification package + decide R1–R5
recommended_sequence_if_PASS (each a SEPARATE sovereign gate):
  1. grammar status-marker AMENDMENT package (authoring → GPT command-review →
     execution) — DML on grammar_profile_status_marker only (B1)
  2. source_document + source_document_version SEED-authoring package (B5),
     after B1–B4 ruled
  3. Constitution DRY-RUN package (isolated env; B6 parser_profile resolved)
  index_DDL_cycle (master-plan Q1/Q2): the 7 pre-scale indexes remain authored
     but unexecuted; the roadmap places index dry-run before dry-run-at-volume.
     RECOMMENDATION: a FIRST small structural Constitution dry-run (enacted_only)
     can precede full volume; exact index-vs-dryrun ordering = GPT decision
     (flagged, not self-decided).
do_not: run dry-run, insert source_document, amend grammar, cut, verify here.

7. Forbidden respected

No CUT. No VERIFY. No Constitution dry-run. No source_document INSERT. No DML. No schema change. No GRANT/REVOKE. No Directus mutation. No vector/NoSQL. No index DDL. No deploy/restart. No git commit. No self-advance. Production contacted only via read-only catalog SELECT; source via one read-only HTTP GET.

8. Git / repo access note

working_directory: /Users/nmhuyen  (NOT a git repo)
iu_cutter_code_repo: not present locally; no branch/HEAD/git-status available
code_changed: false ; commit_made: false ; deploy: none
vps_access: SSH alias 'contabo' — read-only only: docker exec postgres psql
  (information_schema/pg_catalog SELECT) + one read-only `curl` GET of the
  registered source URL. Zero mutation; transient /tmp fetch file removed.
no_write_outside_KB_uploads: confirmed (only the 5 KB docs uploaded)
secrets_in_any_artifact: none

9. Final status

status: CONSTITUTION_SOURCE_GRAMMAR_RATIFICATION__PASS_WITH_BLOCKERS__NOT_DRYRUN_READY
ratification_package_prepared: yes (5 docs)
blockers_open: B1..B6 ; rulings_requested: R1..R5
next_action: STOP — route GPT/User for rulings + closeout of this ratification
self_advance: PROHIBITED

Companion: grounding-report, grammar-applicability-review, source-document-version-plan, status-marker-and-scope-ruling-request.