Opus Review — B2 Rev3 + B3-F1c-H Wrapper Design — For GPT Approval

Date: 2026-05-14 Reviewer: Opus

---

Verdict: ACCEPT cả hai. Ready for GPT approval.

---

B2 Contract Rev3: PASS

Phân loại 4 field rõ ràng, normative, đúng evidence:

• canonical_address → PLACEHOLDER_AT_BIRTH (NULL at birth = expected)
• owner → PLACEHOLDER_AT_BIRTH (resolution algorithm from Rev2 §3 unchanged)
• jsonb_profile → REQUIRED_AT_BIRTH (DEFAULT '{}', keys inside = ENRICHED_LATER)
• identity_profile → NOT_CENTRAL_BIRTH_REGISTRY (per-entity, không add)

Gate invariants đúng: trigger MUST accept NULL canonical_address/owner, MUST accept '{}' jsonb_profile. Không sửa trigger.

B3-F1c-H Wrapper: PASS

Thiết kế đúng "thin adapter" pattern:

• fn_birth_onboarding_full_scan_hc(cfg jsonb) RETURNS boolean
• Gọi scanner → đọc critical_count → so sánh cfg.critical_threshold (default 0) → true/false
• Không EXCEPTION WHEN OTHERS (lỗi propagate, error visibility preserved)
• Không hardcode collection list
• Threshold configurable qua system_health_checks.threshold_config

system_health_checks Row: PASS

• Code: DOT-BIRTH-ONBOARD-FULLSCAN-HC
• executor_type: function, executor_ref: wrapper name
• Jurisdiction NRM-LAW-35-V5P2 — debt accepted, documented, remediation tracked
• check_kind + order_index: TBD via preflight (correct, not hardcoded)

Cron Observation Plan: PASS

7 read-only checks. PASS criteria defined. Explicitly notes observation does NOT prove dispatch_function end-to-end (that needs wrapper + row installed).

Recommended next steps (tuần tự)

Step	Action	Gated by
1	Cron observation (2026-05-15 03:00 UTC)	Time only
2	GPT approve this design	This review
3	Wrapper SQL compile artifact	Cron observation PASS
4	Wrapper DDL execution	GPT approve artifact
5	system_health_checks INSERT	Wrapper installed + preflight
6	Second cron observation	Row inserted
7	B3-F complete declaration	All above PASS

Governance status

b2_rev3_design_review=ACCEPT
b3f1c_h_wrapper_design_review=ACCEPT
system_health_checks_row_design_review=ACCEPT
cron_observation_plan_review=ACCEPT
jurisdiction_debt_accepted=true
execution_allowed=false
birth_complete_allowed=false
phase5c2_resume_allowed=false
next_recommended_action=GPT_APPROVE_THEN_CRON_OBSERVATION_THEN_WRAPPER_COMPILE

Opus Review | B2 Rev3 + B3-F1c-H | 2026-05-14