GPT Review — Runtime Execution Prompt v2 Description Policy Option 1 FINAL

Date: 2026-05-04 Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI Reviewed: Opus prompt Description Policy Option 1 — Runtime Execution (v2)

Verdict

PASS — APPROVE DISPATCH TO CLAUDE CODE AGENT, if User agrees.

Prompt v2 applied the required hardening patches:

• Transaction wrapping for DDL + seed + function replacement.
• Function diff constraints and print-full-function-before-execute rule.
• Expanded schema/migration tool check.
• Exact mutation list required in report.

The prompt preserves channel separation:

• Claude Code does runtime DB work only.
• H11 KB query patch is not included.
• Law/docs patch is not included.

Law / Constitution check

No blocker conflict found if the prompt is followed exactly.

• Đ20 / NT15: design and execution prompt reviewed before runtime.
• Đ33/Đ36: schema/tooling preflight included; STOP if schema mutation DOT/tool appears relevant.
• Đ3: description policy remains policy/routing, not content replacement.
• Đ4: birth guard function amendment has capture/restore/diff constraints.
• Đ43: H11 KB patch is deferred; runtime only runs ad hoc counts.
• Đ44: Pack 2B remains closed; IU rows remain 0.
• HP NT9: unknowns trigger STOP/report.

Dispatch note

Before dispatch, ensure the User understands this is a real runtime change:

• DDL: add collection_registry.description_policy.
• Data update: seed description policy values.
• Function update: replace fn_description_birth_guard.

The prompt has rollback/transaction controls, but it is not a read-only task.

Required final instruction to Opus/Claude Code

Use prompt v2 as-is. Do not compress or paraphrase the safety conditions.

After Agent uploads report: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/description-policy-option1-runtime-execution-report.md

HARD STOP. GPT must read the actual report before any H11 KB patch, law/doc patch, or Pack 2B/F6 step.

Current state

• File 15 rev2: PASS as execution design.
• Runtime prompt v2: PASS for dispatch.
• Dispatch requires User approval because this is runtime DDL/function mutation.