GPT Review — QT-003R Canonical Patch FINAL

Date: 2026-05-04 Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI Reviewed:

• knowledge/dev/architecture/birth-procedures.md rev 5 — v3.1
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reviews/qt003r-canonical-patch-report-2026-05-04.md rev 1
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/12d-iu0-pack2a-qt003r-process-addendum.md rev 1

Verdict

PASS — QT-003R canonical process patch accepted.

Opus correctly patched birth-procedures.md narrowly:

• v3.0 → v3.1.
• Added QT-003R after QT-003 and before QT-005.
• Added summary table row.
• Preserved QT-001/QT-002/QT-003/QT-005/QT-006 content.
• No runtime action, no Claude Code, no Pack 2B.

Law / process check

No blocker conflict found.

• Đ20 / NT15: doc-governance followed design/review before patch.
• Đ43: process now improves graph/process retrieval for future agents.
• Đ4 / birth process: QT-003R fits under collection declaration taxonomy and does not conflict with QT-001/QT-002.
• Đ35/Đ36: QT-003R mandates DOT registration, no raw SQL.
• Đ3: description remains governed by Đ3 §A.3.
• Đ44: IU Pack 2A closure remains valid; Pack 2B still not open.

Resulting state

• Pack 2A core PASS and closed.
• QT-003R is now canonical in birth-procedures.md v3.1.
• F7 scanner tooling issue remains TD, non-blocking for current roadmap.
• F6 remains the next blocking gate before Pack 2B: birth path for IU data rows.

Directive

No further QT-003R patch needed.

Next recommended package, only if User/GPT approves opening it:

F6 — Pack 2B Birth Path Design for IU data rows

Scope should be design-only first, no runtime:

• Use Context Graph + Process Gate.
• Classify IU data-row creation path: QT-002 birth-first vs Đ44-specific integration.
• Resolve information_unit and unit_version birth semantics.
• Decide whether Pack 1 birth gates integrate with birth_registry or need additional DOT/trigger design.
• Address species/description/governance upgrade implications.
• Produce a Pack 2B readiness/design pack before any CRUD pilot.

Hard stop remains: no Pack 2B execution, no IU rows, no CRUD/vector/outbox until F6 design is reviewed and approved.