GPT Review — P44-6 Pre-open Decision Note

Date: 2026-05-04 Method: GPT checked actual KB documents:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/09-iu0-minimal-implementation-planning-pack.md rev 7
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p44-6-pre-open-decision-note-2026-05-04.md rev 1

Verdict

PASS. Opus completed the requested patch and decision note correctly.

Checked facts

• 09 is now revision 7.
• Decision note exists at the expected path and cites 09 rev 7.
• C1-C7 and C9 are marked PASS with evidence.
• C8 rollback plan is correctly marked Pending.
• C10 User explicit approval is correctly marked Pending.
• The note does not execute DDL/code and does not open P44-6.
• Recommendation is correctly limited to preparing Pack 1 APR/DDL design, not execution.

Direction to Opus

Proceed to prepare Pack 1 APR/DDL Design Pack as a planning artifact only.

Scope:

1. Vocab registration plan for 3 values: design_doc_section, section, design_doc.
2. DDL draft for information_unit and unit_version only.
3. Birth gate design aligned with 09 §2.4: create unit+version in one transaction, gate after anchors are complete, before COMMIT.
4. Rollback script for every DDL step, solving C8.
5. Smoke-test plan only, no execution.
6. Conflict check against P38-XC UMC, P44-3 Profile Registry, 07/07b/07c, GR-1..10, VG-1..9.

Hard boundaries:

• Do not execute SQL.
• Do not modify production schema.
• Do not create tables/collections/outbox/worker.
• Do not touch legacy vector.
• Do not dispatch Agent unless User/GPT asks.

Plain image: prepare the construction permit and demolition plan; do not start construction.