GPT Review — P3D TAC→UI Baseline PASS Accepted; Next 5C2 rev3

Date: 2026-05-12 Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI Reviewed:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-pack1-tac-ui-baseline-readonly-check-report.md
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reviews/opus-review-tac-ui-baseline-pass-5c2-prerequisite-satisfied-2026-05-12.md
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/p3d-phase5c2-impact-addendum-after-multidimensional-design.md

Verdict

TAC→UI baseline PASS is accepted.

Agent executed correctly and within read-only boundaries. No supplementary baseline check is required before patching 5C2 rev3.

Accepted evidence

tac_ui_baseline_status=PASS
db_connection_status=RESOLVED
project_root_status=RESOLVED
nuxt_container_status=RESOLVED
source_dir_status=RESOLVED
deploy_root_status=RESOLVED
production_origin_status=RESOLVED
deploy_status=DEPLOYED
table_existence_verified=true
schema_concepts_resolved=true
join_paths_resolved=true
route_files_discovered=true
tac_source_confirmed=true
iu_references_in_laws_page=false
laws_listing_reachable=true
dieu35_reader_reachable=true
dieu35_member_count=36
dieu35_section_type_count=12
baseline_tree_captured=true
hardcode_scan_dynamic=true
no_hardcode_audit_pass=true
no_mutation_performed=true

Critical notes accepted as non-blocking

1. The deployed bundle lacks an embedded git stamp. Equivalence to commit 5ce3437 is inferred, not byte-verified. This is acceptable for the baseline because the live routes return 200 and Laws Page source is confirmed TAC-based. Commit stamping can be handled in a later build/release hardening pack.
2. unit_version_id.* hits in [pubId].vue are TAC FK expansion accessors, not legacy IU references.
3. DB role workflow_admin and DB directus were discovered live. This confirms why fixed postgres/directus constants were not acceptable in earlier prompt versions.

Baseline to preserve

The current UI runtime contract before 5C2 is:

Laws Page is live.
TAC remains the canonical UI source.
IU is not referenced by Laws Page.
DIEU-35 reader is reachable.
DIEU-35 baseline = 36 ordered members, 12 section types, render_order 0–35.
No hardcoded publication-specific UI branching detected.

Decision

Phase 5C2 migration is still not allowed yet, but 5C2 rev3 prompt patching may resume.

Open:

P3D_PACK1_PHASE5C2_REV3_PARALLEL_IU_PILOT_AFTER_TAC_UI_BASELINE

Requirements for 5C2 rev3

5C2 rev3 must incorporate the accepted baseline and foundational design:

1. Explicitly state NO_TOUCH_CURRENT_TAC_UI.
2. Explicitly state PARALLEL_IU_PILOT_ONLY.
3. Explicitly state UI_REDIRECT_FORBIDDEN_UNTIL_VERIFIED.
4. Explicitly state TAC_SOURCE_REMAINS_CANONICAL_FOR_UI_DURING_PILOT.
5. Use baseline values as comparison evidence, not as hardcoded gates unless live source count confirms them at runtime.
6. Re-resolve all schema concepts live before write; no cached column/table assumptions.
7. Preserve Entity Living DB metadata hooks in IU rows.
8. Respect multidimensional metadata principle: the pilot writes one coordinate (species=information_unit_atom, lớp=atom) and must not encode global species/lớp logic.
9. Maintain exact-key rollback and post-rollback verification.
10. No UI cutover; no Nuxt change; no TAC mutation.

Status

tac_ui_baseline=PASS_ACCEPTED
phase5c2_rev3_patch_allowed=true
phase5c2_migration_allowed=false_until_5C2_REV3_APPROVED_AND_USER_GO
ui_cutover_allowed=false
agent_dispatch_allowed=false
next_action=OPUS_PATCH_5C2_REV3_PARALLEL_IU_PILOT