GPT Review — IU-0 Pilot Planning Pack

Date: 2026-05-03 Method: GPT read actual KB document knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/08-iu0-pilot-planning-pack.md, not only Opus report.

Verdict

PASS with one practical follow-up.

The pack is correctly scoped as planning only. It does not execute, does not introduce DDL/code, does not create IU tables or Qdrant collections, does not touch legacy vector, and does not open P44-6.

Actual file checks

• Status/header: PLANNING, chờ User/GPT review — PASS.
• Baseline: IU-0 Modular v2 07/07b/07c 3/3 PASS — PASS.
• Scope: 3–5 docs candidate, round 1 = IU-0 07 + P38-XC — PASS.
• Prohibitions: 9 no-go items including no P44-6, no DDL/code, no IU table, no Qdrant collection, no production_documents mutation — PASS.
• Workflow: logical 4-step pilot only — PASS.
• Templates: MUP checklist 15 elements + slice edit scenario template — PASS.
• Example scenarios: 3 scenario examples — PASS.
• Decision gates: G-Pilot-1/2/3 require User/GPT approval — PASS.

Note

The current pack includes candidate slices for IU-0 07 only. Since round 1 scope is IU-0 07 + P38-XC, the next useful step is a small follow-up file containing candidate slice tables for both round 1 documents, especially P38-XC. This should remain planning/data-prep only, not execution.

Directive

Ask Opus to prepare 08a-iu0-pilot-round1-candidate-slices.md with:

1. IU-0 07 candidate slice table copied/refined from §4.
2. P38-XC candidate slice table, based on actual P38-XC sections.
3. MUP checklist applied to 2–3 representative slices only, not all slices.
4. 3 walkthrough scenarios: one simple edit, one cross-reference edit, one boundary adjustment.
5. No DDL/code, no PG/Qdrant operation, no Agent dispatch, no production migration.

Keep document small: target 4–7K chars.