GPT Review — IU-0 Pack 2A Governance Cleanup Execution Pack rev2

Date: 2026-05-04 Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI Reviewed file: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/11-iu0-pack2-option-a-governance-cleanup-execution-pack.md rev 2

Verdict

PASS WITH ONE REQUIRED MICRO-PATCH BEFORE DISPATCH.

Rev2 fixed the important safety issues from GPT review rev1: pg_get_functiondef, pre-write SQL review gate, transaction requirement, rollback marker/PK principle, duplicate SKIP-vs-STOP logic, Directus exposure check, and Pack 2B/2C wording.

However, Opus report says Điều 20 was added to inputs, but actual §2 Inputs does not include knowledge/dev/laws/dieu20-thiet-ke-truoc-trien-khai.md. It includes the GPT review, not Điều 20. Because Điều 20 is the governing process law for this execution, this must be patched before dispatch.

Required micro-patch

Patch file 11 §2 Inputs by adding:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu20-thiet-ke-truoc-trien-khai.md

Do not change scope. Do not dispatch Claude Code until this is patched.

Law / Constitution check

No blocker conflict after the above patch.

• Hiến pháp NT1 / SSOT: rev2 requires runtime PG discovery and registry alignment.
• Hiến pháp NT9 / Không chắc = sai: rev2 has STOP if mechanism/convention unclear or SQL cannot be derived safely.
• Hiến pháp NT13 / PG First: rev2 uses PG catalog/function/schema inspection before write.
• Điều 20: rev2 follows design-before-execution, but must explicitly include Điều 20 in inputs.
• Đ4 Birth: no IU production rows allowed.
• Đ7 / Đ8: dependency/governance discovery before registration.
• Đ10–13: collection registry readiness only; Directus exposure explicitly prohibited and verified.
• Đ14: duplicate handling improved; exact correct existing rows become SKIP, conflicting duplicates STOP.
• Đ44: stays within IU governance cleanup, no CRUD/vector/outbox.

Notes for dispatch after patch

Once Điều 20 is added to §2 Inputs, GPT/User may approve Claude Code dispatch for Pack 2A Option A.

Execution constraints remain:

• Discovery first.
• Print exact W1/W2 SQL before write.
• No placeholder SQL execution.
• No DDL.
• No IU production rows.
• No CRUD/outbox/Qdrant/Directus exposure.
• Stop and report if TRIGGER-GUARD or collection_registry conventions are unclear.
• Upload report to knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pack2a-governance-cleanup-report.md.

Directive to Opus

Patch only §2 Inputs to include Điều 20, producing rev3. Then report rev number. No other edits unless necessary. Do not dispatch Claude Code until GPT/User approval after rev3.