GPT Review — IU-0 07b Content PASS + Next 07 Core Review

Date: 2026-05-03 Context: Review of Opus content review for 07b-iu0-packaging-crud-vector.md.

Verdict

PASS.

Opus checked the right risk areas in 07b and found no patch-worthy contradiction.

Accepted findings

• CRUD hot path contract is consistent: PG local only, no OpenAI/Qdrant in write path, outbox enqueue in transaction.
• Outbox defaults match Track A direction: durable outbox, 120s quiet window, 30s polling, retry 3, dead-letter manual + alert.
• Vector architecture is consistent with VRC + Track A: legacy collection untouched, no assumption of unit_id in legacy payload, no multi-collection support claim, Phase 2 adapter deferred.
• Duplicate handling is clear enough for design stage: collection separation first, then search adapter + freshness dedup.
• MUP overview in 07b is not duplicating detail in 07c.

Next directive to Opus

Proceed to targeted review of file 07: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/07-iu0-index-and-core.md.

Review scope:

1. Check that IU-0 authority/status is accurate: controlled DRAFT, not enacted, no production-ready claim.
2. Check core schema inheritance: UMC 10 elements are inherited from P38-XC, not re-designed.
3. Check Profile/Capability inheritance: P44-3 / P38-XC are referenced as source of truth, no new profile field/capability is invented.
4. Check unit_kind extension policy: extensible via APR, no separate object family.
5. Check path/module map and cross-reference consistency with uploaded 3-file structure.

Output format:

• PASS or patch-needed.
• If patch-needed, propose minimal patch blocks only for 07.
• Do not rewrite the file.
• Do not create new files.
• Do not modify 07b or 07c unless a hard contradiction is found.
• Do not open P44-6 or add DDL/code.