GPT Review — G-Pilot-5 PASS + Next Directive

Date: 2026-05-04 Method: GPT checked actual Agent Data file knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-closure-decision-pack.md rev 1, not only Opus report.

Verdict

G-Pilot-5 PASS.

Plain-language image

Round 1 proved that instead of lifting the whole cabinet every time we need one folder, we can pull out one folder, edit it, and put it back without disturbing the rest.

Checked facts

• Closure file exists at knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-closure-decision-pack.md rev 1.
• It records G-Pilot-1 through G-Pilot-4 evidence.
• It records 2 writable slice edits PASS: IU-0.§2 with 77% token savings and P38-XC.§4 with 95% token savings.
• It records exact files/revisions changed.
• It clearly states what has not been done: no IU table, no IU Qdrant collection, no outbox worker, no P44-6, no DDL/code/migration, no legacy vector mutation.

Answers to Opus questions

1. Round 1 is COMPLETE.
2. Proceed to Minimal Implementation Planning Pack.
3. Keep GR-2 and GR-3 in force: no DDL/code and no P44-6 in the planning pack. P44-6 only opens after explicit User approval.

Directive to Opus

Create one document only: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/09-iu0-minimal-implementation-planning-pack.md.

Target size: 6–9K chars. Do not split unless it exceeds 10K. Do not create more micro-pilot docs.

Scope:

1. Minimal usable infrastructure target: enough for information units to be created, versioned, read, and edited as slices.
2. Logical schema plan only: information_unit core, unit_version, minimal profile JSONB, and pilot vocab entries.
3. Birth gate plan: 15-element Tier 0 check, with pilot mode allowed as WARN for vocab proposed_pilot.
4. CRUD hot path plan: PG-local writes only, vector/outbox deferred.
5. Outbox plan at logical level only, no worker implementation.
6. Migration/readiness plan: what must be approved before P44-6.
7. Conflict check against IU-0 07/07b/07c, P38-XC, P44-3, GR-1..10, VG-1..9.

Hard boundaries:

• No DDL/code/migration.
• No actual table creation.
• No Qdrant collection.
• No outbox worker.
• No legacy vector mutation.
• No new pilot slice edits.
• No opening P44-6.

Expected output: one uploaded planning pack plus a short report in the reply.