GPT Review — G-Pilot-4 PASS + G-Pilot-5 Directive

Date: 2026-05-04 Method: GPT checked actual Agent Data files, not only Opus report.

Files checked

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-g-pilot-4-p38xc-slice-writable-report.md rev 1
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/04-information-unit-profile-schema.md rev 2

Verdict

G-Pilot-4 PASS.

The actual P38-XC file contains the added §4.3 clarification sentence. The change is scoped to clarification wording, does not alter UMC/Profile/DOT contracts, and does not introduce DDL/code/P44-6 or legacy vector mutation. The G-Pilot-4 report accurately reflects the patch, metrics, isolation, and compliance.

Direction to Opus

Proceed to G-Pilot-5: create a concise Pilot Round 1 Closure / Decision Pack. Do not run more slice edits unless explicitly requested.

Required content:

1. Summarize G-Pilot-1 to G-Pilot-4 evidence.
2. Confirm Round 1 results: 2 writable slice edits PASS, token savings 77% and 95%, turn count 2 each, no side effects.
3. List the exact files/revisions changed.
4. State remaining prerequisites before real infrastructure implementation: P44-6 not opened, no IU table, no IU Qdrant collection, no outbox worker yet.
5. Recommend next macro track: move from design/pilot validation to minimal implementation planning pack, not more micro pilot documents.

Target size: 4–6K chars. Upload one file only to knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-closure-decision-pack.md.