GPT Review — D28 Stage 1 Clean PASS and Stage 2 Dispatch Draft Directive

Date: 2026-05-10
Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI
Reviewed:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/reports/d28-deploy-and-live-smoke-stage1-preflight-report.md rev3
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/prompts/d28-deploy-and-live-smoke-prompt-review.md rev5
• Opus review from user-provided context

Verdict

Stage 1 rev3 clean PASS accepted. Opus review accepted. No rev6 required at this time.

Stage 1 rev3 is eligible as the baseline for Stage 2 approval phrase.

However, because Stage 2 is the first actual production deployment in this chain, GPT does not directly authorize Stage 2 dispatch in this response. The next action is for Opus to prepare a Stage 2 dispatch package draft for User/GPT review, containing the exact approval phrase and hard-boundary reminders.

Stage 1 clean PASS accepted

The report shows:

preflight_status=PASS
status=AWAITING_DEPLOY_APPROVAL
service_name_rule_applied=true
undeclared_substitution_used=false
drift_detected=false
compose_service_name=nuxt
container_name=incomex-nuxt

The clean rev5 Stage 1 run fixes the earlier rev2 issue:

previous rev2 = discovery only, had undeclared substitution at 0D/0G
current rev3 = clean baseline, no substitution, verbatim commands

Stage 1 captured values accepted

Use these Stage 1 values for Stage 2 approval draft:

current_production_image=nuxt-ssr-local:s174
proposed_new_image_tag=nuxt-ssr-local:d2db418
proposed_backup_image_tag=nuxt-ssr-local:pre-d28-rollback-1778397192
proposed_compose_backup_path=/opt/incomex/docker/docker-compose.yml.pre-d28-1778397192
smoke_base_url_mode=PUBLIC_HOST_VIA_NGINX
workflow_sample_discovery=SKIPPED_SAFETY
workflow_tab_smoke=SKIPPED_NO_SAMPLE_ID

Do not use old rev2 values:

old_ts=1778394987

Approval phrase validation

The Stage 2 approval phrase proposed by Agent is correct:

APPROVE D28 DEPLOY: I authorize deploying commits d2db418 + 0947613 as image nuxt-ssr-local:d2db418 to production with brief service interruption, using rollback image nuxt-ssr-local:pre-d28-rollback-1778397192 and compose backup /opt/incomex/docker/docker-compose.yml.pre-d28-1778397192.

This phrase binds to the current clean Stage 1 report values.

Healthcheck finding — accepted as-is

Stage 1 found:

compose_healthcheck_for_nuxt=NONE
dockerfile_healthcheck_directive=NONE
health_check_mechanism=docker_state_running_only

GPT accepts this as-is for this deploy.

No rev6 healthcheck patch is required before Stage 2, because:

• Nuxt has been running stably on current production image;
• Stage 2 already includes docker compose ps nuxt running-state poll;
• Stage 2 includes SSR warmup delay;
• Stage 2 live smoke is the actual readiness validation;
• adding a new route probe inside Phase 1G would duplicate Phase 2 smoke and add complexity at this point.

Recommended note for Stage 2 dispatch package:

Nuxt has no service healthcheck; readiness is validated by running-state poll + 15s warmup + live route smoke. A live smoke failure after restart is treated as deployment regression and may trigger rollback recommendation.

Answer to Opus questions

Q1 — Is Stage 1 rev3 PASS clean enough as Stage 2 baseline?

Yes.

It is clean, rev5-compliant, and has no undeclared substitution.

Q2 — Is the approval phrase correct?

Yes.

Use exactly the phrase shown above, unless User modifies it intentionally. Any modification to tag/path values invalidates Stage 2 binding.

Q3 — Healthcheck finding: accept-as-is or rev6 patch?

Accept-as-is. No rev6 patch.

Q4 — Soạn Stage 2 dispatch package ngay hay another pre-dispatch review?

Soạn Stage 2 dispatch package draft and return for User/GPT review.

Do not dispatch Agent yet.

Directive to Opus

Create a Stage 2 dispatch package draft at:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/prompts/d28-stage2-deploy-live-smoke-dispatch-package.md

The package should be concise and execution-ready for Agent, but marked as draft pending User approval.

It must include:

1. Prompt path:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/prompts/d28-deploy-and-live-smoke-prompt-review.md

2. Run flag:

RUN_STAGE=2_DEPLOY_AND_SMOKE

3. Exact approval phrase:

APPROVE D28 DEPLOY: I authorize deploying commits d2db418 + 0947613 as image nuxt-ssr-local:d2db418 to production with brief service interruption, using rollback image nuxt-ssr-local:pre-d28-rollback-1778397192 and compose backup /opt/incomex/docker/docker-compose.yml.pre-d28-1778397192.

4. Stage 1 report path:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/reports/d28-deploy-and-live-smoke-stage1-preflight-report.md

5. Stage 2 expected report path:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/reports/d28-deploy-and-live-smoke-stage2-execution-report.md

6. Safety reminder:

No Directus mutation.
No PG mutation.
No table_registry mutation.
No publish tbl_event_outbox.
No event_outbox route smoke.
No P3D resume.
No auto rollback.

7. User-facing impact reminder:

This will build and deploy a new Nuxt production image and restart the Nuxt service. Brief 502 errors are expected during the restart window.

8. Rollback approval is separate:

APPROVE D28 ROLLBACK: I authorize restoring compose backup /opt/incomex/docker/docker-compose.yml.pre-d28-1778397192 and bringing up incomex-nuxt with the previous image.

The rollback phrase is for emergency use only and must not be included in the initial Stage 2 dispatch unless User explicitly authorizes rollback after failure.

9. Healthcheck note:

Nuxt has no explicit healthcheck. Readiness is inferred from running state + warmup + live smoke.

10. Expected next pack if Stage 2 PASS:

P3D4C2U_RESUME_NOTIFICATION_DISPLAY_PROMPT_REVIEW

Do not do yet

• Do not dispatch Stage 2.
• Do not deploy.
• Do not restart containers.
• Do not smoke routes.
• Do not publish tbl_event_outbox.
• Do not mutate Directus.
• Do not mutate PG.
• Do not mutate table_registry.
• Do not resume P3D.

Current status

stage1_rev3_outcome=PASS_CLEAN_OUTCOME_A
stage1_baseline_eligible_for_stage2=true
approval_phrase_constructed=true
approval_phrase_signed_by_user=false
stage2_dispatch_allowed=false_until_user_approval
prompt_current_rev=5
prompt_rev6_required=false
build_verify_status=PASS
generated_map_commits=0947613,d2db418
tbl_event_outbox.status=draft
notification_display=paused
p3d_resume_allowed=false

Final status

agent_report=ACCEPTED
opus_review=ACCEPTED
stage1_clean_pass=ACCEPTED
healthcheck_finding=ACCEPT_AS_IS
next_action=OPUS_DRAFT_STAGE2_DISPATCH_PACKAGE
stage2_deploy_allowed=false_until_user_explicit_approval