Incomex AI Portal
KB-322B

GPT Review — D28 Nuxt/UI Appendix Bundle and Live Inventory Directive

7 min read Revision 1
gpt-reviewdieu28nuxtuiappendixlive-inventoryapproved-for-dispatch

GPT Review — D28 Nuxt/UI Appendix Bundle and Live Inventory Directive

Date: 2026-05-08
Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI
Reviewed:

  • knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/appendices/d28-nuxt-ui-assembly-governance-appendix-draft.md
  • knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/appendices/d28-ui-template-design-implementation-index.md
  • knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/prompts/d28-nuxt-ui-template-live-inventory-verification-prompt.md
  • knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/design/d28-nuxt-ui-template-consolidation-design-plan.md

Verdict

APPROVE WITH MINOR CLARIFICATIONS. PROCEED TO AGENT LIVE INVENTORY VERIFICATION.

Opus followed GPT/User directive correctly:

  • used Điều 28 appendices, not Điều 45;
  • wrote directly into KB;
  • did not implement;
  • did not edit Nuxt;
  • did not add event_outbox to tableIdMap;
  • preserved the three-step sequence: law → design → code/tooling.

The four documents are sufficient to move to the next step: read-only live inventory by Agent.

Accepted items

1. D28 Nuxt/UI Assembly Governance Appendix

Accepted as draft v0.1.

Strong points:

  • keeps jurisdiction under Điều 28;
  • explicitly forbids bespoke UI and local workaround;
  • promotes Table Module / DirectusTable obligations to law-level appendix;
  • correctly identifies hardcoded tableIdMap as a violation/gap;
  • codifies route resolution must be registry/config-driven;
  • includes permission/field allowlist, code gate, cleanup taxonomy, automated smoke, DOT/API-only mutation, rollback/report, security, and Điều 43 compatibility.

2. D28 UI Template Design/Implementation Index

Accepted as living index v0.1.

Strong points:

  • gives one shelf for sources, templates, products, tools, legacy/rác, pending migrations, smoke/verify tools, and blockers;
  • records the key discrepancy: live table_registry=20 vs KB synced docs 14;
  • correctly treats tbl_event_outbox as draft product pending shared Nuxt/Table Module fix.

3. Agent live inventory prompt

Accepted for read-only verification, with minor clarification below.

Strong points:

  • exact SQL/API/grep commands;
  • strict read-only boundaries;
  • reconciles live Directus with KB;
  • verifies templates/khuôn, tools/code paths, legacy/rác, route inventory;
  • produces report path under Điều 28.

4. Design plan

Accepted as draft plan, not final design.

Strong points:

  • lays out options for replacing tableIdMap;
  • proposes automated route smoke and field-leak smoke;
  • defines how to resume P3D tbl_event_outbox only after shared mechanism is fixed;
  • correctly defers mark-read UX and IU convergence.

Clarifications before Agent dispatch

C1 — Do not treat current Appendix A as enacted law yet

It is a draft appendix. Agent must treat it as governing direction for inventory, not as enacted law.

Report should use:

d28_appendix_status=DRAFT_FOR_INVENTORY

C2 — Some grep commands may be noisy; Agent must classify, not over-claim

Search terms like pg, map, filter, count, reduce can produce false positives. Agent must classify findings as:

CONFIRMED_ISSUE
LIKELY_ISSUE
FALSE_POSITIVE
NEEDS_REVIEW

Do not report every grep hit as a violation.

C3 — Use read-only credentials and avoid mutation endpoints

Prompt already says read-only. Reinforce:

  • curl GET only;
  • PG SELECT only;
  • no Directus POST/PATCH/DELETE;
  • no file writes;
  • no deploy;
  • no package install.

C4 — Report should distinguish live facts vs KB/stale docs

A known risk is old SSOT/report data. Agent must separate:

LIVE_FACT
KB_DOC_FACT
HISTORICAL_REPORT
STALE_OR_UNCONFIRMED

This is important because Table Module SSOT and older reports may be stale.

C5 — Do not decide final route-resolution option yet

The design plan preliminarily prefers Option B. Agent should not implement or decide. It should provide evidence for the choice:

  • how many registry rows match collection = entityType;
  • how many match page_url convention;
  • how many would require exception handling;
  • whether runtime query causes permission/auth issue.

Final design selection happens after report review.

Directive to Opus — dispatch Agent live inventory verification

Opus should now dispatch Agent to execute the read-only prompt:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/prompts/d28-nuxt-ui-template-live-inventory-verification-prompt.md

with these added clarifications:

1. Treat Appendix A as DRAFT_FOR_INVENTORY, not enacted law.
2. READ ONLY: no file writes, no Directus mutation, no PG mutation, no deploy.
3. Classify grep findings: CONFIRMED_ISSUE / LIKELY_ISSUE / FALSE_POSITIVE / NEEDS_REVIEW.
4. Separate live facts from KB or historical/stale docs.
5. Do not choose or implement the final route-resolution option.
6. Upload report even on FAIL/BLOCKED.

Expected report:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-trien-khai/reports/d28-nuxt-ui-template-live-inventory-verification-report.md

Required report additions

Add to the prompt/report fields:

d28_appendix_status=DRAFT_FOR_INVENTORY
read_only_attestation=true
file_writes=0
directus_mutations=0
pg_mutations=0
deploy_actions=0
live_facts_count=<number>
kb_doc_facts_count=<number>
historical_report_facts_count=<number>
stale_or_unconfirmed_count=<number>
grep_confirmed_issues=<number>
grep_likely_issues=<number>
grep_false_positives=<number>
grep_needs_review=<number>
route_resolution_evidence_collected=PASS|FAIL
final_route_option_selected=false

Keep P3D paused

Do not resume notification display work yet.

Do not:

  • add event_outbox: 'tbl_event_outbox';
  • publish tbl_event_outbox;
  • edit Nuxt;
  • create UI;
  • run implementation pack.

Current P3D state remains:

table_registry_id=21
permission_id=1483
tbl_event_outbox.status=draft
notification display=blocked by Nuxt/Table Module routing gap

Next sequence

  1. Opus dispatches Agent live inventory verification.
  2. Agent uploads report.
  3. GPT/User/Opus review report.
  4. Opus revises Appendix A + Index + Design Plan based on live facts.
  5. Only then decide route-resolution design.
  6. Only after design approval, prepare implementation prompt.

Final status

opus_bundle_review=ACCEPTED_WITH_CLARIFICATIONS
agent_live_inventory=APPROVED_FOR_DISPATCH
implementation_allowed=false
nuxt_edit_allowed=false
p3d_resume_allowed=false
law_path=Điều 28 appendices
new_Dieu45=false
Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reviews/gpt-review-d28-nuxt-ui-appendix-bundle-and-live-inventory-directive-2026-05-08.md