GPT Review — B3-A1b dot_domain_rules Species Mapping Seed PASS — 2026-05-12

Scope reviewed

Reviewed Agent execution report:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-birth-b3a1b-dot-domain-rules-species-mapping-seed-report.md

Related prior artifacts considered:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-birth-b3a1a-species-mapping-seed-report.md
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/p3d-birth-b3a1b-dot-domain-rules-species-decision.md
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-birth-b3a1b-dot-domain-rules-species-decision-report.md

Result

Status: PASS_ACCEPTED

B3-A1b inserted exactly one approved mapping row:

id	collection_name	species_code	is_primary
169	dot_domain_rules	governance_infra	true

Evidence from execution report

• All 14 required gates passed inside a single advisory-locked transaction.
• dot_domain_rules exists in collection_registry.
• dot_domain_rules has coverage_status='BIRTH_REQUIRED'.
• dot_domain_rules has coverage_scope_status='IN_SCOPE'.
• governance_infra exists in entity_species.
• No conflicting prior mapping for dot_domain_rules existed.
• Exact pair was missing before execution and present after execution.
• Rollback key captured: species_collection_map.id = 169.
• Exact rollback SQL logged and scoped by captured id.
• Transaction committed.

Side-effect assessment

Execution report confirms a pre-existing AFTER INSERT trigger on species_collection_map emitted one birth_registry row:

• auto_birth_rows_emitted = 1
• New row represents the mapping row itself: entity_code=species_collection_map::169, collection_name=species_collection_map.
• No dot_domain_rules entity birth occurred.
• Trigger was pre-existing and not created or modified by this session.

This is acceptable and consistent with the approved boundary.

Boundary confirmation

• no_entity_species_insert=true
• no_trigger_created=true
• no_ddl=true
• no_function_patch=true
• no_5c2_migration=true
• no UI cutover
• no B3-A trigger install

Relationship to Opus decision

The seed implements the Opus B3-A1b recommendation: Option A, map dot_domain_rules into existing species governance_infra. The rationale remains accepted: dot_domain_rules is a governance/domain rule table, consistent with other rule/config tables such as nrm_approval_rules, nrm_doc_type_config, label_rules, and universal_rule_registry. No new species was required.

Governance conclusion

B3-A1a + B3-A1b together complete the 8/8 known species mapping gaps from the prior B3-A readiness report, subject to live re-verification. Historical counts must not be used as gates.

Next recommended action

Run B3-A readiness re-check in READ-ONLY mode.

The rerun must:

1. Re-query live collection_registry policy rows.
2. Re-query live species_collection_map coverage.
3. Re-detect triggers by function OID, not by trigger name.
4. Recompute missing species mapping count.
5. Recompute missing trigger count and trigger candidate set.
6. Preserve current prohibitions: no trigger install, no DDL, no function patch, no 5C2 migration, no UI cutover.

Expected focus after rerun:

• Species mapping gaps should become 0 if live state matches reports.
• Remaining blockers likely: variant function bindings, birth_registry recursive/self-birth risk, and clean normative_relations candidate.