GPT Review — B2 Rev3 + B3-F1c-H Dual-Trigger Patch — Approved for Compile Artifacts — 2026-05-14

Scope reviewed

Reviewed rev2 patched documents:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/p3d-birth-b2-contract-rev3-and-b3f1c-h-wrapper-integration-design.md
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-birth-b2-contract-rev3-and-b3f1c-h-wrapper-integration-design-report.md

Previous GPT patch requirement:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reviews/gpt-review-b2-rev3-b3f1c-h-design-dual-trigger-patch-required-2026-05-14.md

Verdict

Status: APPROVED_FOR_COMPILE_ARTIFACTS

The dual-trigger patch is accepted. The design now satisfies the required never-wait model:

• Trigger A: scheduled cron path.
• Trigger B: controlled on-demand path.

Execution is still not approved. Next step is compile-only artifacts for wrapper function and system_health_checks row.

Accepted improvements

• wait_for_cron_required=false.
• Cron observation is diagnostic, not a gate.
• On-demand path is defined.
• No new API endpoint introduced; design stays within PG/DOT domains.
• --dry-run / --only-check are treated as unknown/candidate flags requiring static proof, not assumed truth.
• Current on-demand path is PG_SELECT.
• On-demand scanner invocation is correctly classified as INTENTIONAL_WRITE.
• B2 Rev3 content remains accepted.
• Wrapper direction remains accepted.
• One system_health_checks row remains recommended.

Constitutional / law compliance assessment

Accepted:

• NT7 Dual Trigger: satisfied by scheduled cron + on-demand PG path.
• NT2 Self-Automation: scheduled path remains automated; on-demand path requires authorized runner/report rather than human grep as final mechanism.
• NT5 Self-Detection: scanner writes findings to system_issues; health-check row surfaces them.
• NT12 DOT Pair: scheduled DOT engine + on-demand PG trigger; CLI --only-check remains future DOT enhancement, not assumed.

The design also avoids unnecessary cross-law expansion: no Agent Data endpoint, no Nuxt endpoint, and no new Directus Flow.

Required compile-stage constraints

When compiling wrapper SQL artifact, do not blindly use CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION from the sketch. The artifact must be zero-trust:

1. Check if public.fn_birth_onboarding_full_scan_hc(jsonb) already exists.
2. If absent, compile CREATE FUNCTION only.
3. If present and semantically identical, report PASS_ALREADY_EXISTS / no-op path.
4. If present and different, return BLOCKED_EXISTING_CONFLICT.
5. Do not use CREATE OR REPLACE unless a separate replacement decision is explicitly reviewed and approved.
6. COMMENT ON FUNCTION is optional but should be in a separate, reviewed statement; if included, it is DDL and must be declared.

Required next step

Run compile-only workstream:

B3-F1c-H Wrapper + system_health_checks SQL Artifact Compile

Scope:

• Compile wrapper SQL.
• Compile system_health_checks INSERT SQL.
• Compile rollback SQL.
• Compile on-demand Trigger B2 execution prompt/plan.
• No execution.

Still forbidden

• No CREATE FUNCTION execution.
• No INSERT INTO system_health_checks execution.
• No invocation of fn_birth_onboarding_full_scan().
• No invocation of wrapper.
• No dot-dot-health run.
• No cron changes.
• No Phase 5C2.
• No UI cutover.

Governance status

b2_b3f1c_h_dual_trigger_patch_review_status=APPROVED_FOR_COMPILE_ARTIFACTS
b2_contract_rev3_status=ACCEPTED
wrapper_design_status=ACCEPTED_WITH_CREATE_ONLY_CONSTRAINT
system_health_checks_row_design_status=ACCEPTED_FOR_COMPILE
execution_allowed=false
wrapper_create_allowed=false_until_sql_artifact_review
system_health_checks_insert_allowed=false_until_sql_artifact_review
on_demand_trigger_execution_allowed=false_until_wrapper_and_row_installed_and_authorized
phase5c2_resume_allowed=false
next_recommended_action=AGENT_COMPILE_B3F1C_H_WRAPPER_ROW_AND_ON_DEMAND_TRIGGER_ARTIFACTS