GPT Review — 18b DOT-119 Repair Execution Pack rev3

Date: 2026-05-05 Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI Reviewed: Opus draft 18b — DOT-119 Repair Execution Pack rev3 from conversation

Verdict

PASS as umbrella/gated execution design. Approve next step: draft P0 read-only runtime prompt only.

Rev3 fixes the rev2 blockers:

• 18b is now explicitly an umbrella design, not a one-shot dispatch prompt.
• P0 has a KB report path.
• Schema/migration tool preflight is included.
• HC registration is deferred by default.
• DOT-119 script rewrite requires exact script content in P2, not Claude Code improvisation.
• Exit codes align with 18a rev4.
• IU is dry-run only in 18b; verify belongs to 18c.
• Rollback dependency check is included.
• Manual metadata provenance is included.

Remaining note

Do not dispatch P1/P2/P3 yet. The only approved next runtime action is P0 read-only mapping/preflight.

P0 must not mutate anything. It should only read and upload:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/dot119-repair-p0-readonly-mapping-report.md

After P0 report, GPT/User must review before any DDL/seed/script work.

P0 prompt requirements

Opus should now draft a compact Claude Code prompt for P0 only:

1. Read controlling docs:

   • 18a-dot119-metadata-driven-no-clobber-redesign.md rev4
   • 18b-dot119-repair-execution-pack.md rev3
   • existing-birth-code-column-patterns-report.md

2. Run read-only checks:

   • existing 3 fields absent/present;
   • fn hash baseline;
   • trigger count;
   • birth_registry count;
   • DOT-119 script ls/md5/wc;
   • grep for function replacement;
   • schema/migration DOT tool search;
   • current birth triggers and trigger defs;
   • collection_registry governance roles needed for mapping;
   • information_schema column existence for parsed trigger args.

3. Produce mapping table:

   • collection_name;
   • trigger_name;
   • function_name;
   • trigger_arg;
   • proposed_strategy;
   • proposed_birth_code_column;
   • proposed_source;
   • confidence;
   • notes/provenance.

4. Explicit manual rows:

   • information_unit → synthetic_id, source manual, provenance 18a rev4 + birth-code report.
   • unit_version → subordinate, source manual, provenance 18a rev4.

5. Decision flags:

   • any schema/migration tool relevant? yes/no;
   • any confidence != high? yes/no;
   • are 3 fields already present? yes/no;
   • is DOT-119 stale v1 confirmed? yes/no;
   • is fn hash baseline captured? yes/no.

6. Upload P0 report to KB path above.

7. HARD STOP.

Hard boundaries

• No DDL.
• No UPDATE/INSERT/DELETE to runtime DB.
• No DOT-119 execution.
• No script rewrite.
• No function edits.
• No IU trigger.
• No IU rows.
• No Pack 2B.

Current state

18b rev3 is acceptable as the umbrella plan. The next actual deliverable is a P0 read-only prompt, not execution of DDL/seed/script work.