GPT Review — 12b + File 12 rev3 FINAL before Pack 2A Dispatch

Date: 2026-05-04 Reviewer: GPT-5.5 Thinking / Incomex Hội đồng AI Reviewed:

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/12b-iu0-pack2a-context-graph-gate-application.md rev 1
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/12-iu0-pack2a-dot-governance-registration-execution-pack.md rev 3
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu20-thiet-ke-truoc-trien-khai.md rev 12

Verdict

PASS — READY FOR USER APPROVAL TO DISPATCH CLAUDE CODE FOR PACK 2A DOT GOVERNANCE REGISTRATION.

12b satisfies the new Điều 20 §0 Context Graph Gate requirement. File 12 rev3 correctly references 12b and adds Context Graph Evidence. No further design patch is recommended before dispatch.

What is now fixed

1. Context Graph Gate applied using build 20260504-040018-372b48.
2. Required Đ43 files were read: PROJECT_MAP, LAWS_INDEX, DOT_REGISTRY, DB_MAP, RED_ZONES.
3. Law resolver completed for Đ2, Đ3, Đ4, Đ7, Đ14, Đ20, Đ35, Đ36, Đ43, Đ44.
4. DOT/tool resolver completed for dot-collection-register, dot-collection-health, dot-schema-trigger-registry-ensure, dot-trigger-guard.
5. DB/runtime resolver covers IU tables, registry tables, description config, trigger governance.
6. Red zones are identified and do not conflict with Pack 2A scope.
7. Previous blockers resolved: no raw SQL registry write, no pg_table unsupported source_kind, no raw DELETE rollback, description follows Đ3 §A.3, provenance limited to DOT-channel birth/basic description.

Law / Constitution check

No blocker conflict found.

• Điều 20 §0 / NT15: Context Graph Gate satisfied.
• Đ43 §3.1: context pack read before action; documented in 12b.
• Hiến pháp NT1/NT9/NT13: evidence-first, no guessing, PG/runtime and graph evidence used.
• Đ2/Đ4: registry/birth via DOT tool, not raw code/SQL.
• Đ3: description format and C1-C4 handled.
• Đ35/Đ36: DOT and collection protocol respected.
• Đ7: write path through Directus API as discovered.
• Đ14: duplicate preflight required before write.
• Đ44: Pack 2A remains governance registration only; no CRUD/vector/outbox.

Dispatch guardrails to include

When Opus prepares the Claude Code dispatch prompt, it must point to file 12 rev3 as controlling prompt and include these guards:

1. Use file 12 rev3 as SSOT. Do not improvise beyond it.
2. Before write, verify current state:
   • information_unit and unit_version still missing from collection_registry.
   • IU tables still contain 0 rows.
   • source_kind native accepted by tool/dry-run.
3. If any preflight differs from file 12 rev3, STOP and report. Do not self-correct broadly.
4. Use DOT tools only; no raw SQL write/delete, no DDL.
5. Writes are only the two collection registrations via dot-collection-register and trigger registry sync via approved DOT tool if preflight passes.
6. No Directus exposure, no IU production rows, no CRUD, no Pack 2B/2C, no vector/outbox.
7. Verify with internal and external evidence.
8. Report to: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pack2a-dot-governance-registration-report.md
9. After report upload: HARD STOP.

Directive to Opus/Ocus

No more design patches. Prepare a concise Claude Code dispatch prompt using file 12 rev3 as controlling prompt. Include the dispatch guardrails above. Dispatch only after User approval.

After Claude Code report is uploaded, GPT must review actual report before deciding Pack 2B Minimal CRUD Pilot.