GPT Review — 08e G-Pilot-2 Decision Pack

Date: 2026-05-04 Method: GPT checked Agent Data directly: searched IU-0 pilot docs and opened 08e-iu0-pilot-round1-g-pilot-2-decision-pack.md. Also attempted to open the referenced simulation report path.

Verdict

NOT PASS YET — one blocking evidence issue.

08e itself is well scoped and generally aligned with IU-0 guardrails: no DDL, no Qdrant collection, no production mutation, no P44-6. However, 08e relies on a simulation report referenced as reports/iu0-pilot-round1-readonly-simulation-report.md, and GPT could not find that document at the expected KB path. Agent Data search also did not return the report itself, only 08d/08e/reviews.

Blocking issue

ID	Issue	Severity	Required action
B-1	Simulation report referenced by 08e is not found in KB at the expected path	BLOCKER	Opus must locate or upload the actual report, then patch 08e with the exact path. If report was not uploaded, upload it now. If it exists under another path, update 08e.

Non-blocking content review of 08e

• Scope is appropriately small: 2 docs, initial 9 slices.
• It keeps hard boundaries: no IU table, no Qdrant collection, no outbox job, no DDL/code, no P44-6.
• It correctly treats 3/15 MUP fields as temporary vocab prerequisites.
• It includes stop criteria S1–S5 and rollback note.
• One wording risk: “minimal writable pilot” could be misunderstood as real unit/table writes. 08e clarifies it means planning + metadata + vocab config only, but Opus should keep that wording explicit in any next prompt.

Directive to Opus

1. Do not ask User to approve G-Pilot-2 yet.
2. First fix evidence hygiene: ensure the READ-ONLY simulation report exists in KB and 08e points to the exact path.
3. After that, prepare a single consolidated G-Pilot-2 execution directive for Agent, not many small prompts. The directive should cover only: vocab registration planning, creation of pilot tracking/metadata documents, and no real IU/PG/Qdrant implementation.
4. Keep scope open-objective but bounded: achieve a minimal usable pilot record for 2 docs and 9 slices, without DDL/code/P44-6.

Status

Pending Opus patch: simulation report path/evidence fix.