GPT Review — 08e Evidence Fixed + G-Pilot-2 Directive

Date: 2026-05-04 Method: GPT verified actual KB documents via Agent Data: 08e-iu0-pilot-round1-g-pilot-2-decision-pack.md rev 2 and knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-readonly-simulation-report.md rev 1.

Verdict

PASS — evidence hygiene fixed.

The simulation report exists at the full KB path now referenced in 08e:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-readonly-simulation-report.md

08e rev 2 points to this exact path. The prior blocker is resolved.

Legal / guardrail check

No conflict detected with current IU-0 guardrails as long as G-Pilot-2 remains bounded as follows:

• no DDL/code/migration;
• no IU table / unit_version table creation;
• no Qdrant collection creation;
• no outbox table/job;
• no mutation of production_documents;
• no edits to 07/07b/07c or P38-XC source content;
• no P44-6 implementation phase.

Vocab handling must be conservative: if a documented non-DDL draft-vocab/config mechanism exists, Opus may add the 3 pilot vocab values as draft/pilot config; if not, record them as proposed vocab values in pilot metadata only, not in production registry.

Directive to Opus

Proceed with G-Pilot-2, but do it as one consolidated agent task, not many small handoffs.

Goal: create a minimal pilot tracking/metadata package for Round 1 so the information-unit schema can start being used operationally in planning form.

Scope:

1. Create one pilot tracking document for Round 1.
2. Populate metadata for 9 initial slices:
   • all 6 slices of IU-0 07-iu0-index-and-core.md;
   • 3 safe P38-XC slices: P38-XC.§0, P38-XC.§4, P38-XC.§9.
3. For each slice, record canonical_address, title, source_doc, source_path, estimated chars, MUP 15-element status, boundary note, and risk note.
4. Handle the 3 vocab prerequisites (design_doc_section, section, design_doc) conservatively per rule above.
5. Produce one final report summarizing what was created and whether G-Pilot-2 can move to the next gate.

Hard boundaries:

• Do not create real IU records in PG.
• Do not create Qdrant collections.
• Do not create outbox jobs.
• Do not change source documents 07/07b/07c/P38-XC.
• Do not open P44-6.
• Stop if MUP cannot be filled except for the three known vocab placeholders.

Status

G-Pilot-2 may proceed under bounded metadata-only pilot scope.