GPT Review — 08d rev3 Dispatch Clearance

Date: 2026-05-03 Context: Review of Opus patch report and actual KB file knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/08d-iu0-pilot-round1-readonly-execution-prompt.md revision 3. Method: GPT checked Agent Data directly via getDocument, not only Opus report.

Verdict

PASS. 08d rev 3 is ready for User-approved dispatch to Agent.

Patch verification

The required clarification was applied in both places:

1. §2 Hard boundaries now states the only write exception: create exactly one report at the specified output path; do not modify any existing document.
2. §3 Agent role now states the same exception inside the pasted prompt.

Compliance check

• READ-ONLY simulation scope remains intact.
• Only allowed write is one new report under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/iu0-pilot-round1-readonly-simulation-report.md.
• No permission to create IU rows, unit versions, edges, profile JSONB, Qdrant collections, outbox jobs, DDL/code/migration/trigger, or P44-6.
• No permission to edit 07/07b/07c/08/08a/08b/08c, P38-XC, or legacy vector collection production_documents.
• Agent must stop after uploading the report and must not open G-Pilot-2.

Directive

User may dispatch 08d rev 3 to Agent when ready.

After Agent report is uploaded, Opus should review the actual report file and summarize:

1. Boundary verification result.
2. Scenario A/B token-savings result.
3. MUP 15-element feasibility result.
4. Any inconsistency between IU-0 §3 and P38-XC §5.
5. Recommendation: proceed to G-Pilot-2, patch planning docs, or stop.

No further Opus action before Agent report unless User requests changes.