GPT Review — 08d READ-ONLY Execution Prompt

Date: 2026-05-03 Context: Review of Opus report and actual KB file knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/08d-iu0-pilot-round1-readonly-execution-prompt.md. Method: GPT checked Agent Data directly via getDocument for 08d and searched relevant IU-0/G-Pilot-1 context. Not based only on Opus report.

Verdict

PASS WITH ONE CLARIFICATION PATCH.

08d is correctly scoped as a READ-ONLY simulation prompt. It does not authorize pilot execution, schema creation, Qdrant mutation, outbox creation, code/DDL/migration, P44-6, or modification of existing design files.

Checks

1. Legal / constitutional boundary: PASS. 08d preserves GR-2, GR-3, GR-4, GR-5, GR-9 and stays within Track B design/planning.
2. Scope: PASS. Two scenarios only: Scenario A (IU-0.§2) and Scenario B (P38-XC.§5 + read-only IU-0.§3).
3. No-execute boundary: PASS. HB-1..9 explicitly forbid IU rows, unit versions, edges, Qdrant collections, outbox jobs, code, migrations, edits to existing files, legacy vector mutation, sub-agent dispatch, and P44-6.
4. Output: PASS. The only intended output is one report under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/.
5. Hard stop: PASS. Agent must stop after report upload and must not open G-Pilot-2.

Required clarification patch

08d uses the phrase “CHỈ ĐƯỢC ĐỌC tài liệu từ KB. KHÔNG tạo/sửa/xoá bất cứ gì” while later allowing upload of one report. This is understandable but could confuse an execution agent.

Patch request: add one sentence in §3 under “Vai trò”, and optionally in §2:

Ngoại lệ ghi duy nhất được phép: tạo mới đúng 1 report tại path output đã chỉ định; không sửa bất kỳ tài liệu hiện có nào.

No other content changes required.

Directive to Opus

Patch 08d with the clarification above, then stop. Do not dispatch Agent yet. After patch, report revision number and wait for User/GPT approval to dispatch.

No-go boundary

Do not start Track C. Do not implement IU schema. Do not create tables, collections, outbox jobs, code, or migrations. Do not modify 07/07b/07c/08/08a/08b/08c except the single clarification patch to 08d.