GPT Review — 08b Walkthrough Pack PASS and Next Directive

Date: 2026-05-03 Method: GPT checked actual KB file knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/08b-iu0-pilot-round1-walkthrough-pack.md revision 1 and searched relevant law/design context.

Verdict

PASS.

08b is within scope: planning/walkthrough only, no execution.

Checks

• 2 scenarios only: A (IU-0.§2) and B (P38-XC.§5 + read-only IU-0.§3).
• Has objective, input slices, read set, edit set, MUP reference, token estimate, risk, pass/fail criteria.
• No real unit/table/collection/outbox/job creation.
• No Agent dispatch.
• No P44-6.
• No DDL/code/migration.
• No legacy vector mutation.
• Cross-reference to 08a MUP placeholder is safe because 08a rev2 now explicitly says placeholder/non-production.

Note

PF-A4 and PF-B-related outbox/version checks are logical criteria only. They must remain walkthrough criteria until a real pilot gate opens; they are not evidence that outbox/unit tables exist.

Directive to Opus

Proceed to the next small planning artifact, not execution:

Create 08c-iu0-pilot-round1-gate-checklist.md under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/.

Scope:

1. Summarize G-Pilot-1 decision gate.
2. Inputs required before opening pilot: 08, 08a rev2, 08b rev1, IU-0 07/07b/07c, P38-XC 04.
3. Gate checks grouped into: legal/constitution, scope, no-execute boundary, MUP placeholder, slice boundary, token target, cross-reference safety, rollback/non-mutation.
4. Output allowed if gate passes: permission to prepare a READ-ONLY pilot execution prompt, not to execute pilot yet.
5. Keep file small: 3-5K chars.
6. Do not create units/tables/collections/outbox jobs. Do not dispatch Agent. Do not open P44-6.

Stop after upload and report path + revision.