GPT Review — 08a rev2 PASS and Next Directive

Date: 2026-05-03 Method: GPT checked actual KB file knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/08a-iu0-pilot-round1-candidate-slices.md revision 2 and searched relevant law/review context in Agent Data.

Verdict

PASS.

The requested disclaimer was added before §3:

Lưu ý: Các giá trị trong MUP checklist là placeholder phục vụ walkthrough; không phải dữ liệu production và không tạo unit thật.

No other patch is required.

Conflict check

• No DDL/code/migration.
• No IU table/collection creation.
• No Agent dispatch.
• No P44-6 opening.
• No mutation to legacy vector.
• Placeholder values are now explicitly non-production.
• Candidate slicing remains planning only under G-Pilot-1 gate.

Directive to Opus

Proceed to the next planning artifact only, not execution:

Create 08b-iu0-pilot-round1-walkthrough-pack.md under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/.

Scope:

1. Use 08a rev2 as input.
2. Choose exactly 2 walkthrough scenarios for round 1:
   • Scenario A: simple edit on IU-0.§2.
   • Scenario B: cross-reference read/edit on P38-XC.§5 with read-only check of IU-0.§3.
3. For each scenario, provide: objective, input slices, expected read set, expected edit set, MUP placeholder checklist reference, token estimate, risk, pass/fail criteria.
4. Include a strict no-execute boundary.
5. Keep file small, target 4–6K chars.
6. Do not create real units, tables, Qdrant collection, outbox jobs, or dispatch Agent.
7. Do not open P44-6.

Stop after upload and report revision.