GPT Review — 08a IU-0 Pilot Round 1 Candidate Slices

Date: 2026-05-03 Method: GPT read actual KB document knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/08a-iu0-pilot-round1-candidate-slices.md, P38-XC source 04-information-unit-profile-schema.md, and relevant law snippets (Đ14, Đ10-13, Đ15-16, Đ43, IU-0 07/07b/07c). Not based only on Opus report.

Verdict

PASS with one minor clarification request.

08a is correctly scoped as planning only. It does not execute, does not create tables/collections, does not mutate legacy vector, and keeps G-Pilot-1 as a User/GPT decision gate.

Checks

1. Actual file check

• 08a exists at the expected path, revision 1.
• It contains IU-0 07 candidate slices and P38-XC candidate slices.
• It includes 2 representative MUP checklists only, not all slices.
• It includes 3 walkthrough scenarios: simple edit, cross-reference edit, boundary adjustment.
• It includes a round-1 risk checklist and gate reminder.

2. P38-XC alignment

PASS.

P38-XC actual document has top-level sections §0–§14. 08a's 15 top-level candidate slices match this structure.

08a correctly identifies P38-XC §5, §7, §8, §14 as longer candidates and recommends split/keep decisions at planning level only.

3. Constitutional / law conflict check

PASS.

• Đ14 no-duplicate: 08a does not create duplicate data; it only maps candidate slices. Duplicate content handling remains in IU-0 07b §6.
• Đ10-13 operations/lifecycle: 08a does not mutate; scenario C uses retire/create as a walkthrough only. Real execution remains gated.
• Đ15-16 checkpoint/state: 08a preserves G-Pilot-1 and does not self-open gates.
• Đ43 system context: path is under dieu44-trien-khai/design/, consistent with current Đ44 design folder practice.
• P38-XC / IU-0: no re-design of UMC/Profile/Capability; 08a only prepares candidate slice boundaries.

4. Minor clarification needed

In the MUP checklist samples, values like owner_ref = opus, owner_lookup_ref = opus, publication_authority_ref → Đ44/Đ38 are marked as “dự kiến.” To avoid future agents mistaking them for real production data, add one sentence:

“Các giá trị trong MUP checklist là placeholder phục vụ walkthrough; không phải dữ liệu production và không tạo unit thật.”

This is a small patch only; no rewrite.

Directive

Ask Opus to patch 08a with the clarification sentence above, then stop. After that, 08a can be treated as PASS for G-Pilot-1 review.

Next step after patch: prepare a concise Round 1 Walkthrough Pack (08b) only if User/GPT approves G-Pilot-1.