dot-iu-cutter v0.6 Orchestrator O3 Live Read-only Discovery PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-21 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-orchestrator-o3-live-readonly-discovery/ Current-state pointer: knowledge/current-state/reports/dot-iu-cutter-v0.6-o3-live-readonly-discovery-pass-2026-05-21.md

Verdict

orchestrator_O3_live_readonly_discovery: PASS
result: O3_LIVE_READONLY_DISCOVERY_PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
effort_high: SUFFICIENT
production_mutation: NONE
live_CUT_VERIFY_enact: NONE
repo_feature_HEAD: 3d26a09
repo_main_HEAD: 4649423
execution_enabled: false
next_path_selected: PATH_FF_O3_TO_MAIN
next_effort: medium

O3 is accepted. The orchestrator can now discover live production state through a read-only injected select_rows path and build per-run RunContext.context_pins without hardcoded runtime IDs/secrets or live mutation.

Accepted facts

live_access:
  role: context_pack_readonly
  transaction: read_only
  write_privileges_on_IU_UV_lifecycle_log: false

live_constitution_state:
  ICX_CONST_total: 60
  ICX_CONST_draft: 0
  ICX_CONST_enacted: 60
  unit_version_enacted_at_nonnull: 60
  iu_lifecycle_log_rows: 60
  drift_class: post_enactment_expected

orchestrator:
  LiveReadOnlyDiscoverer: added
  context_pins_source: live_data_per_run
  execution_enabled: false
  Mode_LIVE: refused
  tests: 362/362 PASS

Safety accepted

not_done:
  - production_mutation
  - live_CUT
  - live_VERIFY
  - live_enactment
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag
  - hardcoded_secret_or_runtime_id

Effort policy update

default_effort:
  medium:
    - local fast-forward hygiene
    - report/index/readme cleanup
  high:
    - live read-only discovery
    - non-mutating adapter integration
    - governance/reporting macros
  xhigh:
    - live production mutation orchestration
    - deploy architecture
    - real crypto/signing replacement
    - state-machine redesign

Ruling

O3: CLOSED_PASS
selected_next: PATH_FF_O3_TO_MAIN
reason:
  - O3 code is tested and feature branch is ahead of main by one commit
  - aligning main before O4 reduces repo ambiguity
  - task is simple repo hygiene, medium effort is sufficient

Authorized next macro-goal

next_phase: v0_6_main_fast_forward_after_O3_live_readonly
scope:
  - verify feature HEAD 3d26a09 and main HEAD 4649423
  - verify clean tree and ff-only feasibility
  - run lightweight checks or full discover if feasible
  - fast-forward local main to 3d26a09 if gates pass
  - no push/tag/deploy/restart
  - no production mutation

Deferred paths

deferred:
  O4_live_dry_run_orchestration:
    effort: high_or_xhigh
    note: if read-only/sandbox only then high; if any live mutation or sovereign approval handling then xhigh
  deploy_contabo:
    effort: high_or_xhigh
  real_crypto_signing:
    effort: xhigh

Final status

status: O3_CLOSED_PASS__MAIN_FF_NEXT_MEDIUM
next_action: run_medium_main_ff_after_O3