dot-iu-cutter v0.6 Orchestrator O2 E2E Authoring PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-orchestrator-o2-phase-body-e2e-authoring/

Verdict

orchestrator_O2_E2E_authoring: PASS
result: ORCHESTRATOR_O2_E2E_AUTHORING_PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_mutation: NONE
live_execution: NONE
repo_feature_HEAD: 4649423
repo_main_HEAD: 35ca9e1
full_discover: 359/359 PASS
killswitch_execution_enabled: false
next_agent: Codex
next_effort: high
next_path_selected: PATH_FF_O2_TO_MAIN

The O2 authoring macro is accepted. The v0.6 orchestrator now has phase bodies, gate invariant predicates, simulator-backed mutating phase paths, resume handshake, STOP-doc emission, and in-memory E2E tests while keeping live execution disabled.

Accepted implementation facts

commit:
  hash: 4649423
  parent: 35ca9e1
  branch: feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
  main_unchanged: 35ca9e1

tests:
  before: 308
  after: 359
  result: 359/359 PASS

orchestrator:
  phase_bodies: 11/11 filled
  gate_invariants: 41/41 filled
  todo_o2_remaining: 0
  live_mode_guarded: true
  killswitch: false

Accepted safety facts

safety:
  production_mutation: false
  live_CUT_VERIFY_enact: false
  deploy_restart: false
  push_tag: false
  source_mutation: false
  hardcoded_secrets: false
  module_level_PIN: false
  v0_5_modules_touched: false
  fake_PASS: false

Ruling

O2: CLOSED_PASS
selected_next: PATH_FF_O2_TO_MAIN
reason:
  - O2 is tested and feature->main is linear per report
  - main should be aligned before O3 live read-only discovery work
  - task is repo hygiene, suitable for high or medium; user requested Codex/high

Authorized next macro-goal

next_phase: v0_6_main_fast_forward_after_O2_authoring
scope:
  - Codex reads KB SSOT first
  - verify feature HEAD 4649423 and main HEAD 35ca9e1
  - verify clean tree and ff-only feasibility
  - run lightweight checks or full discover if feasible
  - fast-forward local main to 4649423 if gates pass
  - upload reports
  - no push/tag/deploy/restart
  - no production mutation

Deferred paths

deferred:
  O3_live_readonly_discovery:
    effort: high_or_xhigh
    note: LiveDiscoverer against read-only psycopg; killswitch remains off
  tag_remote_push:
    note: requires release/remote policy
  contabo_deploy:
    note: separate deploy package
  real_crypto_signing:
    note: separate security architecture track

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production mutation
  - live orchestrator execution
  - enabling production execution kill-switch
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag remote
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - real crypto replacement
  - hardcoded secrets/runtime ids

Final status

status: O2_CLOSED_PASS__CODEX_HIGH_MAIN_FF_NEXT
next_action: handoff_to_codex_for_main_fast_forward_after_O2