dot-iu-cutter v0.6 Orchestrator O1 Authoring PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-orchestrator-o1-authoring/

Verdict

orchestrator_O1_authoring: PASS
result: ORCHESTRATOR_O1_AUTHORING_PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_mutation: NONE
live_execution: NONE
repo_feature_HEAD: 35ca9e1
repo_main_HEAD: 0a64a61
full_discover: 308/308 PASS
next_path_selected: PATH_FF_O1_TO_MAIN_THEN_O2

The O1 authoring-only macro is accepted. The orchestrator skeleton, contracts, state model, gate model, policy hooks, sidecar store, approval validator, batch runner, reporter/discoverer seams, and phase modules are in place without production execution.

Accepted implementation facts

commit:
  hash: 35ca9e1
  parent: 0a64a61
  files_added: 28
  loc_added: 2256
  ratified_v0_5_files_touched: false

orchestrator_modules:
  python_modules_under_cutter_agent_orchestrator: 24
  states: 14
  phases: 11
  internal_gates: 11
  sovereign_gates: 3
  stop_route_classes: 17
  new_tests: 43

Accepted safety invariants:

invariants:
  no_user_artifact: enforced_and_tested
  no_module_level_PIN_constants: enforced_and_tested
  secret_shaped_pin_refusal_and_strip: enforced_and_tested
  live_mode_refused: enforced_and_tested
  no_silent_retry: enforced_and_tested
  sovereign_authority_preservation: enforced_and_tested

Ruling

O1: CLOSED_PASS
selected_next_1: PATH_FF_O1_TO_MAIN
selected_next_2: O2_PHASE_BODY_AND_IN_MEMORY_E2E_AUTHORING
PATH_FF_O1_TO_MAIN_effort: medium
O2_effort: xhigh

Fast-forward main first because O1 is already tested and feature->main is reported feasible. Then run O2, which is larger and should use xhigh because it fills phase bodies and gate predicates.

O2 boundary

O2_scope:
  - fill 10 stub phase bodies where safe
  - implement GATE_INVARIANTS predicates
  - add in-memory E2E orchestration tests
  - no production execution
  - no live CUT/VERIFY/enact
  - no deploy/restart/push/tag

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production mutation
  - live orchestrator execution
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag remote
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - real crypto replacement
  - hardcoded secrets/runtime ids

Final status

status: O1_CLOSED_PASS__MAIN_FF_THEN_O2_XHIGH
next_action: run_medium_main_ff_O1_to_main_then_xhigh_O2_authoring