dot-iu-cutter v0.6 Main FF After O2 PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-main-fast-forward-after-o2-authoring/

Verdict

PATH_FF_O2_TO_MAIN: PASS
result: MAIN_FF_O2_TO_MAIN_PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
main_HEAD: 4649423
feature_HEAD: 4649423
current_branch: main
production_mutation: NONE
live_orchestrator_execution: NONE
execution_enabled: false
next_phase: O3_LIVE_READONLY_DISCOVERY
next_effort: high

The local main branch now contains the O2 orchestrator implementation. Tests remain clean and the production execution kill-switch remains disabled.

Accepted facts

repo:
  main: 4649423
  feature_constitution_snapshot_mark_dryrun: 4649423
  current_branch: main
  working_tree_clean: true
  remote_count: 0
  tag_count: 0

checks:
  tests: 359/359 PASS
  execution_enabled: false

not_done:
  - push
  - tag
  - deploy
  - restart
  - production_mutation
  - live_orchestrator_execution

Ruling

O2_MAIN_LOCAL: CLOSED_PASS
selected_next: O3_LIVE_READONLY_DISCOVERY
reason:
  - O2 in-memory E2E is complete and on main
  - the next risk to reduce is live read-only discovery against real DB/KB state
  - no mutation or live cut is required
  - high effort is sufficient unless schema/permission/orchestrator design diverges

O3 scope

O3_scope:
  - implement or complete LiveDiscoverer read-only integration
  - connect with read-only credentials only
  - prove orchestrator can survey live production state and build RunContext/context_pins
  - run read-only live discovery against the already-completed Constitution document or a harmless target
  - keep Mode.LIVE refused / execution_enabled false
  - no production mutation
  - no CUT/VERIFY/enact execution
  - no deploy/restart/push/tag

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production mutation
  - live CUT/VERIFY/enact
  - enabling production execution kill-switch
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag remote
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - real crypto replacement
  - hardcoded secrets/runtime ids

Final status

status: O2_ON_MAIN__O3_LIVE_READONLY_DISCOVERY_NEXT_HIGH
next_action: run_high_effort_O3_live_readonly_discovery_macro