dot-iu-cutter v0.6 Main FF After O1 PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.6-main-fast-forward-after-o1-authoring/

Verdict

PATH_FF_O1_TO_MAIN: PASS
result: MAIN_FF_O1_TO_MAIN_PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
main_HEAD: 35ca9e1
feature_HEAD: 35ca9e1
production_mutation: NONE
orchestrator_execution_enabled: false
next_phase: O2_PHASE_BODY_AND_IN_MEMORY_E2E_AUTHORING
next_effort: xhigh

The local main branch now contains the v0.6 orchestrator O1 skeleton. The production execution kill-switch remains off.

Accepted merge facts

main:
  before: 0a64a61
  after: 35ca9e1
feature_constitution_snapshot_mark_dryrun:
  after: 35ca9e1
merge_type: ff-only
commits_added: 1
files_changed: 28
insertions: 2256
conflicts: 0
working_tree: clean
remote: none
tag: none
deploy: none
push: none

Accepted checks

checks:
  orchestrator_import: PASS
  milestone: O1
  execution_enabled: false
  pytest_discover: 308/308 PASS

Ruling

O1_MAIN_LOCAL: CLOSED_PASS
selected_next: O2_PHASE_BODY_AND_IN_MEMORY_E2E_AUTHORING
reason:
  - O1 skeleton/contracts are now on main
  - O2 fills phase bodies and gate invariant predicates
  - in-memory E2E tests can materially validate orchestration before any live execution
  - architectural complexity warrants xhigh

O2 boundaries

O2_scope:
  - implement phase bodies against in-memory/discoverer/reporter seams where safe
  - implement GATE_INVARIANTS predicates
  - add in-memory E2E orchestration tests
  - keep Mode.LIVE refused / execution_enabled false
  - no production DB mutation
  - no live CUT/VERIFY/enact
  - no deploy/restart/push/tag

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production mutation
  - live orchestrator execution
  - enabling production execution kill-switch
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag remote
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - real crypto replacement
  - hardcoded secrets/runtime ids

Final status

status: O1_ON_MAIN__O2_XHIGH_AUTHORING_NEXT
next_action: run_xhigh_O2_phase_body_and_in_memory_E2E_authoring