dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Schema Q5 + Command Review Planning — GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-18 Reviewer: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-schema-q5-command-review-planning/

Reviewed files:

files:
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-schema-Q5-scope-and-object-inventory-2026-05-18.md
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-schema-Q5-command-sequencing-and-gates-2026-05-18.md
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-schema-Q5-verification-and-rollback-master-plan-2026-05-18.md
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-schema-Q5-open-decisions-and-risk-register-2026-05-18.md
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-schema-Q5-command-review-planning-report-2026-05-18.md

Verdict

schema_Q5_command_review_planning_package: PASS_WITH_RULINGS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
opus_review: CORRECT
forbidden_respected: true
self_advance_respected: true
planning_complete: true
execution_authorized: false

The planning package is accepted. It correctly converts the 21-file design authority into an implementation route with object inventory, sequencing, gates, verification/rollback, open decisions, and risk controls.

However, this review does not authorize execution. The next phase may author executable DDL for review, but must not run it.

---

Rulings on blocking decisions

BR-A1 — canonical address separator final lock

ruling: LOCKED
canonical_address_scheme: "<DOCPREFIX>/<L1>-<L2>-...-<Lk>"
docprefix_separator: "/"
hierarchy_level_separator: "-"

This is now formal lock for Schema Q5 authoring. Future DDL/design must treat slash as the document-prefix/path separator and hyphen as the hierarchy-level separator. Status markers remain outside canonical address.

OD-SEQ1 — source_document registry precedence

ruling: APPROVE_SOURCE_DOCUMENT_AS_WS_Q5_STEP_0

Source document registry must be included as WS-Q5 step 0 / prerequisite because docprefix, source_version, grammar profile binding, and canonical address templates depend on it.

OD-SEQ2 — registries before vocab/checker

ruling: FULL_REGISTRY_SUBSTRATE_FIRST

Order is:

1: WS_Q5_registry_substrate
2: evidenced_by_vocab_amend
3: Cap_4_checker_extension

Reason: implementing evidenced_by before the registry/fabric substrate risks creating an edge type without the surrounding source/authority/entity registry needed to use it safely.

OD-SEQ3 / OD-SEQ2 in Opus report — index lane

ruling: KEEP_INDEX_DDL_AS_SEPARATE_CYCLE

Do not bundle the 7 pre-scale indexes into the first WS-Q5 schema authoring package. Index DDL already has a dedicated authoring package and should remain a separate dry-run → command-review → execution cycle.

OD-VC2 — vocab physical shape

ruling: DEFER_TO_WS_VA_AUTHORING_AFTER_WS_Q5

Do not decide or author the physical evidenced_by vocab entry in the first WS-Q5 DDL package. It belongs to a later WS-VA authoring phase after WS-Q5 registry substrate is reviewed.

OD-VC1 — edge_type namespace scheme

ruling: DEFER_TO_WS_VA_AUTHORING

For WS-Q5 authoring, only reserve compatibility with owner_law_code=NRM-LAW-44 and the future vocab framework. Do not solve P44-4-alpha in WS-Q5 DDL authoring.

OD-VC3 — checker deploy strategy

ruling: DEFER_TO_WS_CK_AUTHORING

Cap-4 checker deployment design belongs after WS-Q5 and WS-VA. Do not include checker deployment in first registry DDL package.

OD-VC6 — authority_semantics vs owner_law alignment

ruling: KEEP_DISTINCT_LAYERS

authority_semantics remains an Information Unit Fabric/source assembly role. owner_law_code remains a P44 vocab/governance tag. Do not merge them.

---

Approved immediate next phase

Open a narrow DDL authoring phase for WS-Q5 registry substrate only:

next_phase: v0_5_WS_Q5_registry_substrate_DDL_authoring
nature: executable_DDL_authoring_only__no_execution

Scope:

include:
  - source_document_registry / source_document_version_registry if needed as Step 0
  - source_family_registry
  - grammar_profile registry/config
  - entity_kind_registry
  - entity_reference_registry
  - authority_override registry
  - metadata_key_registry

exclude:
  - evidenced_by vocab amend
  - Cap-4 checker code/config implementation
  - pre-scale 7 index execution
  - topic_vocab physical table unless explicitly required as non-blocking defer
  - assembly_profile physical table unless explicitly required for first substrate
  - reverse-index P1/P2/P3
  - release_bundle
  - Constitution dry-run
  - CUT/VERIFY

The phase may produce executable SQL DDL artifacts for GPT/User command review, plus rollback SQL and verification plan. It must not run the SQL.

---

Required authoring constraints

constraints:
  - author SQL only, do not execute
  - additive only unless a conflict is discovered and escalated
  - deterministic names
  - no DML seed execution; seed data may be authored separately as draft only if needed
  - include IF NOT EXISTS only where it does not hide incompatible existing definitions
  - structural verification must use catalog-level checks, not rendered-string equality
  - rollback must be exact inverse, safe, and no CASCADE unless explicitly justified
  - preserve SQL SSOT, PG First, Assembly First, no hardcode

---

Still forbidden

still_forbidden:
  - executing SQL
  - schema migration apply
  - production write
  - data migration/backfill
  - vocab amend execution
  - Cap-4 checker code/config change
  - index DDL execution
  - Directus mutation
  - vector/NoSQL integration
  - CUT
  - VERIFY
  - dry-run
  - deploy/restart
  - git commit
  - Agent self-advance to command execution

Final status

status: PLANNING_PASS_WITH_RULINGS
next_action: open_WS_Q5_registry_substrate_DDL_authoring_only