dot-iu-cutter v0.5 S2 to CUT Capability Readiness — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-19 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-s2-to-cut-capability-readiness/

Verdict

macro_goal_prompt_effectiveness: HIGH
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
result_type: DUAL_RESOLUTION
selected_direction: D_SPLIT_PLANNER_AND_WRITER
production_mutation: NONE
CUT_authorized: false
VERIFY_authorized: false

The open-goal prompt was more effective than the prior micro-task style. In one pass the Agent:

agent_achieved:
  - rebuilt current code/S2 state
  - tested S2 and MARK locally
  - identified S2 as a planner, not a writer
  - inspected production schema read-only
  - discovered the true writer target is public.information_unit + unit_version birth-gate, not v0.4 ledger families
  - separated planner readiness from production writer gap
  - returned a minimal unblock path without inventing production commands

Accepted results

CUT_PLANNER_S2:
  status: READY_FOR_S2_COMMIT_REVIEW
  files:
    cutplan.py: 548eabc5...
    tests/test_cutplan_snapshot.py: 06e871e7...
  tests:
    cutplan_targeted: 15/15 PASS
    mark_entrypoint: 21/21 PASS
    discover: 128/1 with known baseline security-test issue
  production_writer: false

PRODUCTION_CUT_WRITER:
  status: BLOCKED_WITH_EXACT_IMPLEMENTATION_GAP
  target_model: public.information_unit + unit_version two-layer birth-gate
  existing_ICX_CONST_rows: 0
  key_gaps:
    - writer manifest/cutplan to information_unit/unit_version not implemented
    - N2 mapping/granularity not ruled for production writer
    - vocab dot_config seed not complete
    - credential/signing path not built
    - production-write approval not issued

Process lesson

lesson:
  keep_open_goal_prompts: true
  avoid_micro_tasks_when_no_production_mutation: true
  use_macro_checkpoints: true
  stop_only_at: blocker_or_production_gate_or_sovereign_decision

Ruling

P_track_planner:
  next: COMMIT_REVIEW_AND_COMMIT_S2_PLANNER_IF_STILL_CLEAN
  production_write: not_allowed

W_track_writer:
  next: WRITER_MAPPING_AND_BIRTH_GATE_DESIGN
  production_write: not_allowed

recommended_order:
  - commit S2 planner because it is ready and independent
  - in the same macro phase, draft writer mapping/birth-gate design if time permits
  - do not execute CUT or VERIFY

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - execute CUT
  - execute VERIFY
  - write production DB
  - deploy/restart
  - merge/push/tag
  - mutate source_document/source_version
  - invent pseudo production command
  - self-advance to production execution

Final status

status: S2_PLANNER_READY_FOR_COMMIT_REVIEW__WRITER_GAP_CONFIRMED__OPEN_GOAL_STYLE_CONFIRMED
next_action: macro_task_commit_S2_planner_and_prepare_writer_design_track