dot-iu-cutter v0.5 S2 Planner Commit + Writer Bridge — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-19 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-s2-planner-commit-and-writer-design-bridge/

Verdict

macro_task_result: PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
S2_planner: COMMITTED
writer_design_bridge: READY
production_mutation: NONE
CUT_authorized: false
VERIFY_authorized: false
open_goal_prompt_effectiveness: HIGH

The macro/open-goal prompt was effective. In one task, the Agent committed the S2 planner and prepared the writer design bridge without production mutation.

Accepted planner facts

planner_track:
  branch: feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
  pre_commit_HEAD: afb7bfcc9b7bbb953bb00159479c9611e6ac4bd1
  post_commit_HEAD: d66a60d9d7d11d60366825b08e0ea3d5d2d6aeef
  commit_subject: "feat: add S2 no-DB CUT-plan dry-run planner (cutplan) + tests"
  files_committed:
    - cutter_agent/cutplan.py
    - tests/test_cutplan_snapshot.py
  tests:
    cutplan: 15/15 PASS
    mark: 21/21 PASS
    discover: 128/1 with known baseline security-test issue
  merge_push_deploy: false

Accepted writer bridge facts

writer_track:
  target_model: public.information_unit + unit_version two-layer birth-gate
  mapping_direction: 60 cut-plan rows -> 60 information_unit rows + 60 unit_version rows
  recommended_unit_kind: law_unit
  recommended_granularity: all 60 rows are IU rows
  top_level_parent: null for top-level rows; hierarchy stored via parent_or_container_ref where applicable
  idempotency_guard: canonical_address UNIQUE + manifest/cutplan digest precheck
  birth_pattern: INSERT information_unit -> INSERT unit_version -> UPDATE version_anchor_ref in one transaction
  vocab_gap: reduced to precheck; required values appear already seeded
  production_writer_code: not authored yet

Ruling

selected_next_macro_goal: CUT_PLAN_DRYRUN_AND_WRITER_DECISION_PACKAGE
style: open_goal_prompt
micro_task_split: avoid

Next task should combine two non-production tracks:

next_tracks:
  P3_cutplan_dryrun:
    objective: run or prepare the first no-DB cut-plan dry-run from existing manifest, if safely possible
    mutation: artifact_only
  W1_writer_decisions:
    objective: resolve or propose rulings for OD-W1..OD-W9 and prepare writer authoring package
    mutation: design_only

The next task may proceed through checkpoints without returning after each small step. It must stop before any production write, CUT execution, VERIFY execution, deploy, merge, or push.

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production CUT execution
  - VERIFY execution
  - production DB write
  - production IU creation
  - deploy/restart
  - merge/push/tag
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - invent production writer command before writer is built and gated

Final status

status: S2_PLANNER_COMMITTED__WRITER_BRIDGE_READY__NEXT_MACRO_CUTPLAN_DRYRUN_AND_WRITER_DECISIONS
next_action: run_open_goal_macro_for_cutplan_dryrun_and_writer_decision_package