dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Production leg-A Mode Final Approval Ready — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-production-legA-mode-final-approval-ready/

Verdict

macro_task_result: A_READY_FOR_GPT_GRANT_AND_PRODUCTION_CUT_EXECUTION_APPROVAL
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_leg_A_mode: BUILT_TESTED_COMMITTED
production_mutation: NONE
GRANT_authorized: not_yet
CUT_authorized: not_yet
VERIFY_authorized: not_yet
macro_task_scale_policy: can_increase_to_45_60_minute_tasks_when_no_production_mutation

The larger task was successful. The Agent implemented R1, committed it on the feature branch, ran targeted tests, re-verified live state read-only, and stopped before every production mutation gate.

Accepted code facts

repo_branch: feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
pre_commit_HEAD: 152e7db
post_commit_HEAD: f20c79c
modified_files:
  - cutter_agent/prod_iu_adapter.py
  - cutter_agent/cutprod.py
  - tests/test_prod_iu_adapter.py
tests:
  prod_adapter: 37/37 PASS
  cutwrite: 22/22 PASS
  MARK: 21/21 PASS
  cutplan: 15/15 PASS
  targeted_total: 95/95 PASS
  wider: 139/140 with known baseline PGPASSWORD-literal heuristic issue
production_connect_attempted: false
production_mutation: NONE

Accepted live state

live_reverify:
  schema_drift: false
  information_unit_cols: 19
  unit_version_cols: 16
  L1_md5: f38c94d0...
  L2_md5: 078ba005...
  vocab: 6/6
  ICX_CONST_existing_rows: 0
  cutter_exec_cutter_verify_grants_on_public_targets: absent_as_expected

Ruling

A1_GAP_A1: CLOSED_BY_R1_PRODUCTION_LEG_A_ONLY_MODE
A2_GD1: APPROVE_DIRECTUS_AS_GRANT_APPLY_PRINCIPAL
A3_U_W4b: READY_FOR_SCOPED_GRANT_EXECUTION_APPROVAL
A4_C5: READY_FOR_SOVEREIGN_PRODUCTION_WRITE_APPROVAL_FOR_LEG_A_CUT

This does not itself execute GRANT or CUT. It confirms that the next execution macro can be prepared with explicit gates.

Process ruling: larger task size

macro_task_policy:
  recommended_size: 45_to_60_minutes_when_no_production_mutation
  allowed_inside_one_task:
    - read SSOT and inspect repo/schema
    - author local code
    - run tests
    - run scratch/isolated dry-runs
    - prepare execution packages
    - execute gated production action only if the prompt explicitly grants that action and defines prechecks/rollback/reporting
  must_stop_before_if_not_explicitly_authorized:
    - production GRANT/REVOKE
    - production CUT
    - VERIFY
    - deploy/restart
    - merge/push/tag

Authorized next macro-goal

next_phase: v0_5_first_controlled_CUT_execution_macro_with_internal_gates
scope:
  - re-confirm KB and live prechecks
  - execute scoped GRANT only if its prechecks pass
  - verify GRANT
  - execute production leg-A CUT only if GRANT and all drift/backup/command integrity checks pass
  - upload execution reports
  - prepare VERIFY request/report after CUT
  - stop before VERIFY unless explicitly authorized in the same prompt

Because the user wants fewer orchestration turns, the next prompt may combine GRANT execution and CUT execution, but only with strict internal stop gates. VERIFY may be prepared but should remain a separate execution gate unless the prompt explicitly authorizes it.

Still forbidden until the next prompt explicitly authorizes them

forbidden_now:
  - execute production GRANT/REVOKE
  - execute production CUT
  - execute VERIFY
  - production DB write
  - production IU creation
  - deploy/restart
  - merge/push/tag
  - mutate source_document/source_version

Final status

status: LEG_A_MODE_READY__GRANT_AND_CUT_APPROVAL_READY__AWAITING_EXECUTION_PROMPT
next_action: issue_macro_prompt_for_scoped_GRANT_then_leg_A_CUT_with_internal_stop_gates