dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Production Bridge to CUT Approval Readiness — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-19 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-production-bridge-to-cut-approval-readiness/

Verdict

macro_task_result: B_BRIDGE_PARTIALLY_READY_WITH_EXACT_FINAL_GATE
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
macro_task_scale: EFFECTIVE_AND_CAN_BE_INCREASED_CAREFULLY
production_mutation: NONE
CUT_authorized: false
VERIFY_authorized: false

The larger open-goal task was effective. The Agent handled a wider scope, corrected a prior false blocker (C2), produced a scoped credential/GRANT package, clarified the signing posture, and prepared the production adapter/CUT command-review bridge without production mutation.

Accepted corrections and state

C2_governed_ledger_location:
  ruling: RESOLVED
  finding: v0.4 ledger is live in directus.cutter_governance, same DB as public.information_unit/unit_version
  implication: single-DB single-transaction CUT is feasible; no cross-DB ledger work needed

C1_credentials:
  ruling: GRANT_PACKAGE_READY_FOR_REVIEW
  finding: cutter_exec/cutter_verify have zero privileges on public.information_unit/unit_version/dot_config target path
  implication: scoped credential/GRANT command-review is needed before production writer

C3_signing:
  ruling: ACCEPT_RD_C3_FOR_CONTROLLED_FIRST_CUT_UNLESS_USER_OVERRIDES
  posture: StubSigning + lane-overlap invariants allowed for controlled first CUT, matching v0.4 precedent; real crypto deferred

C4_prod_adapter:
  ruling: DESIGN_READY_CODE_WITHHELD_CORRECTLY
  note: connect-capable adapter code deserves its own gated authoring/execution boundary

C5_sovereign_write_approval:
  ruling: STILL_REQUIRED

Process ruling: larger macro-tasks are allowed

prompt_scale_policy:
  default_size: larger_medium_to_large_macro_task
  allowed_scope_before_stop:
    - investigate
    - design
    - local code authoring
    - local tests
    - scratch/isolated dry-runs
    - command-review package authoring
  mandatory_stop_before:
    - production DB write
    - production GRANT/REVOKE execution
    - production CUT execution
    - VERIFY execution
    - deploy/restart
    - merge/push/tag

The user guidance is accepted: prompt must state goal, definition of done, and forbidden methods clearly, then let the Agent choose the path.

Authorized next macro-goal

next_phase: v0_5_final_bridge_to_production_CUT_command_review_package
scope:
  - finalize credential/GRANT command-review package
  - if possible, author guarded production adapter locally and test it without production write
  - assemble production CUT command-review package using the resolved bridge
  - prepare production execution checklist, backup, drift checks, verification, compensation
  - stop before any actual GRANT, production DB write, CUT, VERIFY, deploy, merge, or push

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - execute production GRANT/REVOKE
  - execute production CUT
  - execute VERIFY
  - write production DB
  - production IU creation
  - deploy/restart
  - merge/push/tag
  - mutate source_document/source_version
  - run writer against production DB in write mode
  - self-advance to production execution

Final status

status: PRODUCTION_BRIDGE_PARTIALLY_READY__C2_RESOLVED__GRANT_PACKAGE_READY__LARGER_MACRO_NEXT
next_action: run_large_open_goal_for_final_bridge_to_production_CUT_command_review_package