dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Lifecycle DDL Ratification Runbook PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-lifecycle-ddl-ratification-runbook/

Verdict

PATH_1_B_DDL_RATIFY: PASS
result: LIFECYCLE_DDL_RATIFIED_IN_REPO_PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_mutation: NONE
next_path_selected: PATH_R1_MAIN_FAST_FORWARD_AFTER_RATIFY
next_effort: high

The lifecycle DDL/runbook ratification is accepted. The live lifecycle functions and triggers are now captured in repo runbook artifacts using byte-equal live pg_proc.prosrc fingerprints, avoiding divergence from authored SQL formatting.

Accepted repo facts

repo:
  pre_HEAD_main: 32cfa93
  post_commit_feature: 1cd286e
  main_untouched: true
  files_added: 11
  location: sql/lifecycle/
  size: 67KB
  production_DDL_executed: false
  lifecycle_mutation: false
  deploy_restart: false
  push_tag: false

Accepted fingerprint pins

fingerprints_md5_prosrc:
  fn_iu_enact: 6ca9bc39e2d2be93dd8a71739fa80dc4
  fn_iu_apply_edit_draft: 42e96b6c9e81a2d0a28b30644d178a26
  fn_iu_enacted_immut: aeb3fa4fdb225f6ba6b7073582caa454
  fn_uv_enacted_immut: 03f035a23cbc79a9e811a6da6f5266ba

Accepted critical finding:

kb_authoring_sql_vs_live_prosrc:
  divergence: expected
  reason: PostgreSQL strips inline comments and normalizes source text
  repo_policy: preserve live prosrc-byte-equivalent runbook artifacts

Ruling

selected_next: PATH_R1_B_MAIN_FF_AFTER_RATIFY
reason:
  - feature commit 1cd286e preserves production-live lifecycle DDL runbook
  - main currently lacks this runbook
  - fast-forward is low risk and should happen before automation/deploy planning
  - no production mutation is involved

Authorized next macro-goal

next_phase: v0_5_main_fast_forward_after_lifecycle_DDL_ratify
scope:
  - verify feature HEAD 1cd286e and main HEAD 32cfa93
  - verify ff-only feasibility
  - run relevant tests/static checks
  - fast-forward local main to 1cd286e if all gates pass
  - no push/tag/deploy/restart

Deferred paths

deferred:
  PATH_R2_light_followups:
    effort: high
  PATH_R3_automation_orchestrator_design:
    effort: xhigh
  PATH_R4_deploy_v0_5_contabo:
    effort: high_or_xhigh

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production DDL
  - lifecycle mutation
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag remote
  - hard delete
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - real crypto replacement

Final status

status: LIFECYCLE_DDL_RUNBOOK_RATIFIED__MAIN_FF_NEXT
next_action: run_high_effort_main_fast_forward_after_DDL_ratify