dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Full-Document Trial Design GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-17 Reviewer: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-full-document-trial-design/

Verdict

v0_5_full_document_trial_design: PASS_WITH_BLOCKERS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
design_only_boundary: respected
full_document_cut_allowed_now: false
hien_phap_cut_allowed_now: false
second_IU_allowed_now: false
bulk_cut_allowed_now: false

The v0.5 design correctly identifies that a full-document cut is materially different from the validated single-IU trial. It also correctly surfaces scale blockers before attempting Hiến pháp or any multi-IU document.

Accepted Findings

already_cut_documents:
  DIEU_28: 27_rows
  DIEU_32: 23_rows
  DIEU_35: 36_rows
storage_SSOT:
  - public.tac_logical_unit
  - cutter_governance
hien_phap_in_system: false
hien_phap_requires_external_authoritative_source: true
estimated_leaf_IUs_clause_point: 300_to_500
estimated_governance_rows_clause_point: 5000_to_7500
single_IU_delta_invariant: 15

Critical Blockers Before Full-document Execution

blockers:
  B1_authoritative_source_ingestion: open
  B2_pre_scale_index_only_DDL: open_required
  B3_label_metadata_registry_design: open_required_before_large_scale_labeling
  B4_multi_level_canonical_address_grammar_for_Chuong: open
  B5_existing_corpus_tier_normalization_DIEU32_DIEU35: open
  B6_dry_run_at_volume: open
  B7_manifest_strategy_per_IU_vs_document_level: open

Rulings on Key Design Directions

trial_mode: dry_run_first_then_staged_production_small_batch
big_bang_full_document_production: rejected
hien_phap_immediate_execution: rejected
merge_storage: same_SQL_SSOT_no_new_store
NoSQL_vector: projection_search_only_not_authority
rollback_policy_multi_IU: per_IU_forward_compensation_no_document_wide_delete
manifest_strategy_preference: per_IU_envelope_initially_to_preserve_validated_plus15_invariant

Index / Scale Decision

Pre-scale index-only DDL is a hard prerequisite before any full-document or high-volume batch. The current governance tables are correct but not yet performance-safe for hundreds/thousands of IUs.

index_DDL_needed_before_full_document_cut: true
index_DDL_must_be_separate_cycle: true
index_cycle_must_include:
  - design
  - DDL_authoring
  - dry_run
  - command_review
  - production_execution
  - backup_restore_verification

Label / Metadata Decision

The user's scale concern is accepted as a binding architecture requirement. Full-document and future millions-of-IUs workflows require an extensible metadata/label strategy.

label_metadata_registry_required_before_large_scale_labeling: true
no_new_label_columns_by_default: true
labels_must_not_be_hardcoded_in_runtime: true
JSONB_allowed_for_sparse_evolving_metadata_but_not_hidden_authority: true
hot_keys_need_promotion_index_policy: true
SQL_SSOT_for_governance_identity_lifecycle: true
vector_NoSQL_projection_only: true

Data-quality Decision

DIEU_32_DIEU_35_blank_tier: accepted_finding
normalization_required_before_using_existing_corpus_as_scale_fixture: true
normalization_must_be_separate_read_review_write_cycle: true

Next Recommended Phase

Do not proceed to Hiến pháp cut. Open the pre-scale foundation work first.

Recommended immediate next phase:

phase: v0_5_pre_scale_index_and_label_metadata_foundation_design
nature: design_only

Required outputs:

required_documents:
  - pre_scale_index_hot_path_analysis
  - index_only_DDL_design_for_cutter_governance_runtime_paths
  - label_metadata_registry_concept_design
  - information_unit_extensible_metadata_strategy
  - existing_corpus_tier_normalization_plan
  - full_document_dry_run_at_volume_plan
  - phase_report

Still Forbidden

forbidden:
  - full_document_CUT_VERIFY
  - Hien_phap_cut
  - second_production_IU
  - bulk_cut
  - production_reclassification_batch
  - deploy_or_restart
  - index_DDL_execution
  - label_registry_schema_creation
  - vector_NoSQL_integration
  - alias_writes

Status

ready_for_pre_scale_foundation_design_prompt: true
agent_self_advance_to_execution: prohibited