dot-iu-cutter v0.5 First Snapshot MARK Dry-run Duplicate Resume Guard — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-19 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT

Verdict

duplicate_resume_guard: PASS_CORRECT
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
re_run_authorized: false
existing_first_dryrun_PASS: ACCEPT_AS_AUTHORITATIVE
CUT_authorized: false
VERIFY_authorized: false

The Agent correctly detected that the task premise was stale. The KB SSOT already contains a completed first snapshot MARK dry-run PASS from 2026-05-19 with the full deliverable set in the target output folder. Re-running it as a "resume" would violate the "execute exactly once" instruction and risk overwriting ratified deliverables.

Accepted existing dry-run facts

existing_dryrun:
  status: PASS
  date: 2026-05-19
  output_folder: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-constitution-first-snapshot-mark-dryrun-output/
  branch: feature/constitution-snapshot-mark-dryrun
  HEAD: afb7bfcc9b7bbb953bb00159479c9611e6ac4bd1
  dryrun_py_sha: f1f42e83...2efa1422
  fixture_region_sha: 17660443...cae80c
  length: 17522
  markers: enacted=19,controlled_draft=1,draft=1,obsolete=1
  exit_code: 0
  db_write: NONE
  production_touched: false
  candidate_count: 60
  manifest_digest: 9d908a62...
  re_run_equal: true
  P_checks: PASS
  V_checks: PASS
  QG_checks: PASS

Ruling

R1_accept_existing_PASS: APPROVED
R2_fresh_rerun: REJECTED_UNLESS_EXPLICITLY_AUTHORIZED_AS_RERUN_OVER_EXISTING_OUTPUTS
R3_next_phase: REVIEW_EXISTING_DRYRUN_OUTPUTS_AND_DECIDE_CUT_READINESS

Do not re-run the dry-run. Treat the existing 2026-05-19 PASS package as the authoritative first dry-run result.

Required next phase

Open a review phase over the existing dry-run outputs:

next_phase: v0_5_first_snapshot_MARK_dryrun_output_review_and_cut_readiness
nature: review_only__no_CUT_no_VERIFY

Purpose:

purpose:
  - inspect the existing dry-run manifest/review/coverage/determinism/report outputs
  - confirm candidate_count and emitted levels
  - confirm enacted_only purity and Điều 44 exclusion
  - confirm canonical address uniqueness and coverage/no-overlap
  - identify any parser/matcher/manifest issues before CUT
  - recommend whether to proceed to CUT command-review or fix the entrypoint/manifest first

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - re-run first dry-run unless explicitly authorized as a fresh rerun
  - CUT
  - VERIFY
  - production IU creation
  - production DB writes
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - schema change
  - Directus/vector writes
  - deploy/restart
  - merge to main
  - push/tag/remote
  - self-advance to CUT/VERIFY

Final status

status: EXISTING_FIRST_DRYRUN_PASS_ACCEPTED__NEXT_REVIEW_OUTPUTS
next_action: review_existing_dryrun_outputs_and_assess_CUT_readiness