dot-iu-cutter v0.5 First Controlled Canonical CUT PASS — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT

Verdict

first_controlled_canonical_CUT: PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_rows_persisted: true
VERIFY_authorized_in_prior_task: false
leg_B_governed_recording_authorized_in_prior_task: false
next_task_scale: 45_to_60_minute_macro_task

The first controlled Constitution CUT succeeded through the canonical fn_iu_create() path. The gateway was not bypassed and direct INSERT was not used.

Accepted production result

production_delta:
  information_unit: 98 -> 158
  unit_version: 105 -> 165
  birth_registry: +60
  ICX_CONST_IUs: 60
  anchor_updates: 60
  gateway_bypassed: false
  canonical_path: fn_iu_create SECURITY DEFINER
  lifecycle_status: draft
  publication_type: law
  sysid: 7611578671664259111

Accepted structural facts:

structural_result:
  distinct_canonical_addresses: 60
  anchored_exact: 60
  distinct_content_hashes: 60
  levels:
    NGUYEN_TAC: 15
    KIEN_TRUC_SECTION: 3
    DIEU: 42
  dieu_44_present: 0
  writer_digest_equivalence: proven

Process lesson

prompt_scale_lesson:
  45_to_60_minute_tasks: approved_default_for_high_capability_agent
  key_requirements:
    - live survey before action
    - clear objective
    - definition_of_done
    - explicit forbidden list
    - internal gates before mutation
    - allow autonomous technical fixes inside scope

The Agent correctly performed an in-scope technical fix to the provider autocommit behavior after proving the issue with rollback-only probes. This is acceptable autonomy: it was not architecture improvisation, did not bypass policy, and was fully documented.

Authorized next macro-goal

next_phase: v0_5_post_CUT_VERIFY_governed_recording_and_release_readiness
scope:
  - run/author VERIFY updated for canonical row shape
  - execute VERIFY if prechecks pass and read/write scope is approved by the package
  - close or package leg-B governed recording within audit-debt window
  - assess lifecycle draft -> enacted workflow need
  - prepare code commit/merge ratification plan for canonical adapter changes
  - prepare next automation/orchestrator plan

This next task may be broader than prior tasks. It may include VERIFY execution and governed recording only if the task prompt explicitly authorizes those actions and the Agent confirms all gates. It must stop before enactment mutation, deploy, merge/push, or any unapproved production mutation.

Still forbidden until next prompt explicitly authorizes

forbidden_now:
  - enactment workflow mutation
  - deploy/restart
  - merge/push/tag
  - hard delete
  - unapproved leg-B recording SQL
  - unapproved VERIFY writes
  - source_document/source_version mutation

Final status

status: CANONICAL_CUT_PASS__60_IU_LIVE__VERIFY_AND_GOVERNED_RECORDING_NEXT
next_action: run_45_60_min_macro_for_VERIFY_legB_recording_and_release_readiness