KB-780A

dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Constitution Source Seed From Snapshot Execution BLOCKED by Environment — GPT Review

4 min read Revision 1

dot-iu-cutterv0.5constitution-fixturesource-seed-from-snapshotblockedenvironment-capability-gapgpt-reviewrerun-same-packagedieu442026-05-18

dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Constitution Source Seed From Snapshot Execution BLOCKED by Environment — GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-18 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed reported package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-constitution-source-document-seed-from-snapshot-production-execution/

Verdict

execution_status: BLOCKED_CORRECTLY
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
root_cause: environment_capability_gap
DML_defect: false
package_reauthoring_needed: false
production_mutation: none
rollback_needed: false
B5_status: OPEN

The Agent correctly stopped because the current session could not satisfy the mandatory execution gates. This is not a defect in the approved DML package.

Accepted blocker facts

prechecks:
  P1_target_structure: PASS
  P2_supporting_registry_state: NOT_SATISFIED_due_to_context_pack_readonly_no_USAGE_on_cutter_governance
  P3_existing_source_rows: NOT_SATISFIED_due_to_context_pack_readonly_no_USAGE_on_cutter_governance
  P4_snapshot_rehash: PASS
  P5_command_integrity: PASS

execution_capabilities:
  fresh_backup: NOT_POSSIBLE_no_pg_dump_tool
  execute_as_workflow_admin: NOT_POSSIBLE_only_readonly_query_pg_no_write_SSH_path

Because P2/P3 could not be proven and backup/workflow_admin execution were unavailable, stopping before DML was mandatory.

Ruling

same_approved_revised_DML_package: REMAINS_VALID
same_execution_approval: REMAINS_VALID_SUBJECT_TO_CAPABLE_ENVIRONMENT
re_author_DML: NOT_REQUIRED
retry_from_readonly_context: REJECTED

Do not re-author the DML. Do not adapt DML on the fly. Re-run the same approved package only from an environment that has the required capabilities.

Required execution environment

The next attempt must run from an environment with:

required_environment:
  - read access to cutter_governance for P2/P3 catalog and row checks
  - pg_dump or approved production backup capability
  - ability to execute as workflow_admin or the approved schema-owner role
  - access to the revised DML package from KB
  - access to snapshot artifact for rehash
  - ability to upload the 3 required execution reports to KB

The Contabo/VPS SSH -> docker postgres workflow previously used for production DDL/seed phases is the recommended channel.

Required next action

next_phase: v0_5_constitution_source_seed_from_snapshot_production_execution_rerun_capable_env
nature: controlled_execution__same_approved_package__no_reauthoring

The phase should read:

authority:
  - final command-review approval
  - revised DML package
  - this environment-blocked review

and then run P1-P5, backup, execute, verify, report, STOP.

Still forbidden

still_forbidden:
  - DML execution from read-only or underprivileged context
  - skipping P2/P3 row absence checks
  - skipping fresh backup
  - using directus/context_pack_readonly for apply
  - adapting DML on the fly
  - ON CONFLICT masking
  - seeding any other document/version
  - Constitution dry-run
  - CUT
  - VERIFY
  - schema change
  - GRANT/REVOKE
  - Directus mutation
  - deploy/restart
  - git commit
  - self-advance after execution

Final status

status: BLOCKED_BY_ENVIRONMENT_ONLY__RERUN_SAME_APPROVED_PACKAGE_FROM_CAPABLE_ENV
next_action: rerun_controlled_execution_via_VPS_workflow_admin_channel