dot-iu-cutter v0.5 — Constitution Hardtest Design GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-17 Reviewer: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-constitution-hardtest-design/

Verdict

v0_5_constitution_hardtest_design_package: PASS_WITH_GATES
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
design_only_boundary: respected
nothing_executed: true
cat_hien_phap_allowed_now: false
constitution_dry_run_allowed_now: false
index_execution_allowed_now: false
bulk_cut_allowed_now: false

The Agent completed the requested design-only master-plan phase correctly. The package contains all 8 required documents, preserves all forbidden boundaries, and correctly identifies the critical source/grammar mismatch.

Critical review finding

F1_source_identity_correction: CONFIRMED_AS_BLOCKING_GATE

The configured source URL does not represent the Vietnamese national 2013 Constitution. The Agent’s read-only grounding reports that the source is the internal Hiến pháp Kiến trúc Hệ thống Incomex v4.6.3 with structure based on Nguyên tắc, Kiến trúc Hạ tầng A/B/C, and Mục lục Luật Điều 0..44, including enacted/draft markers. Therefore, the prior handoff assumption of a Chương / Điều / Khoản / Điểm / đoạn legal grammar is invalid for this fixture.

This is not a failure. It is a useful hardtest result. The system must be registry/profile-driven and must not hardcode a national-law grammar into all documents named Hiến pháp.

Package assessment

required_docs_present: true
source_registry_design: present
ingestion_pipeline_design: present
canonicalization_grammar_design: present
label_metadata_registry_design: present
scale_index_roadmap: present
sql_nosql_projection_design: present
risk_gate_plan: present
design_report: present
anti_hardcoding_principle: pass
SQL_SSOT_principle: pass
vector_projection_only: pass
forward_compensation_not_delete_rollback: pass

The design is accepted as a master plan. It correctly reframes the goal from “cut one document” to “build an information-unit factory with source authority, versioning, grammar profiles, provenance, metadata registry, scale indexes, dry-run-at-volume, and staged production rollout.”

Decisions now required

Before any Constitution dry-run, the following decisions must be explicitly ratified:

OD_G1:
  question: Is the hardtest fixture the internal Incomex Architecture Constitution v4.6.3, not the Vietnamese national 2013 Constitution?
  GPT_default: YES, treat current URL as internal architecture constitution fixture.

OD_G2:
  question: What is the leaf-IU granularity for this fixture?
  GPT_default: grammar-profile-driven; do not assume Điều-only. Require parser sample and leaf policy review before volume.

OD_S1:
  question: Is the source authority sufficient, and should controlled-draft sections such as 📋 Điều 44 be excluded from production cuts?
  GPT_default: exclude controlled-draft content from production CUT unless separately authorized; allow it only in design/parser dry-run as draft-marked fixture.

OD_M1:
  question: Should manifests be per-IU or document-level for full-document operations, and how does that affect the +15 invariant?
  GPT_default: keep per-IU manifest for first hardtest dry-run to preserve v0.4 invariant; evaluate document-level/batched manifest only in a separate design after volume metrics.

Routing ruling

Although the Agent recommended Q1 index dry-run as the general sequenced next step, GPT reroutes based on the critical OD-G1 finding:

recommended_next_phase: v0_5_source_and_grammar_ratification_for_internal_constitution_fixture
nature: design_plus_read_only_grounding_only

Reason: executing index dry-run is useful, but not the main blocker exposed by this hardtest. The main blocker is that the source identity and grammar profile must be ratified before any document-specific pipeline or dry-run. Running index dry-run first would not answer whether the pipeline can correctly understand and segment this actual source.

Next Agent directive

Open a narrow read-only/design phase:

phase: v0_5_source_and_grammar_ratification_for_internal_constitution_fixture
output_path: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-source-grammar-ratification/

Objectives:

1. Confirm source identity from the configured URL and record a stable source fingerprint.
2. Produce a source authority/eligibility ruling draft.
3. Extract a small representative structure sample without cutting anything.
4. Propose grammar profile incomex_architecture_constitution_v4 or a better deterministic name.
5. Propose canonical address namespace scheme for this document family.
6. Propose leaf-IU granularity options and recommend one.
7. Decide how enacted vs controlled-draft markers should be represented in design.
8. Recommend whether controlled-draft sections are excluded from production CUT by default.
9. Keep index execution, dry-run-at-volume, CUT/VERIFY, schema changes, and code changes forbidden.

Forbidden until separately authorized

forbidden:
  - Cắt hiến pháp execution
  - Constitution dry-run
  - run CUT or VERIFY
  - second production IU
  - bulk cut
  - any production write
  - index DDL execution
  - schema migration
  - label/metadata registry creation
  - tier-normalization write
  - vector/NoSQL integration
  - alias writes
  - deploy/restart
  - code change
  - Agent self-advance across gates

Review status

review_status: PASS_WITH_GATES
next_action: source_and_grammar_ratification_prompt_to_Agent