dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Constitution CUT Command Review BLOCKED — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-19 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-constitution-cut-command-review/

Verdict

cut_command_review_package: PASS_AS_BLOCKED_WITH_EXACT_GAP
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_mutation: NONE
CUT_authorized: false
VERIFY_authorized: false
next_mode: macro_goal_not_micro_task

The Agent correctly refused to invent a production CUT command. The existing committed MARK entrypoint is dry-run/manifest-only. A snapshot-manifest-to-CUT capability is not yet committed/ratified for production use.

Accepted blocker summary

blockers:
  GAP_1: no committed snapshot_manifest_to_CUT entrypoint
  GAP_2: S2 cutplan.py and tests exist as untracked/unfinished work, not committed or gated
  GAP_3: no implemented writer from 60 candidates to public.information_unit
  GAP_4: credential/signing production path not built
  GAP_5: production-write approval and governed verification path not ready

Accepted invariants

cut_input_invariants:
  source_document_version_id: icxconst-008a06ace23a96ea6cd456146e805c97
  scope: enacted_only
  candidate_count: 60
  manifest_digest: 9d908a62...
  dieu_44: excluded
  draft_obsolete: excluded
  canonical_DIEU_addresses: fixed
  production_write: forbidden_until_explicit_CUT_approval

Ruling

selected_next_macro_goal: S2_TO_PRODUCTION_CUT_CAPABILITY_READINESS
style: open_goal_prompt
not_selected: isolated_commit_gate_only

The next Agent task should not be a tiny commit S2 task. It should be a broader capability-readiness task: investigate S2, finish or reject it, test it, determine the minimum production CUT capability, and return either a complete commit/command-review path or an exact implementation gap.

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - execute CUT
  - execute VERIFY
  - write production DB
  - deploy/restart
  - merge/push/tag
  - mutate source_document/source_version
  - invent pseudo command
  - self-advance to production execution

Final status

status: CUT_COMMAND_REVIEW_BLOCKED_ACCEPTED__MACRO_CAPABILITY_TRACK_NEXT
next_action: run_open_goal_S2_to_CUT_capability_readiness_task